
Supreme Court: Shastri Bhavan Library Relocation Halted Until November 20
Summary
- The Supreme Court intervened in the planned relocation of the 135-year-old Shastri Bhavan library due to the Central Vista redevelopment.
- The Centre assured the Supreme Court that the library would not be moved before November 20, following concerns raised by the Amicus Curiae.
- The Amicus Curiae reported insufficient space at the proposed temporary premises and highlighted 2 lakh books lying in cartons since 2011.
- Justice Sanjay Kumar expressed strong displeasure over the authorities' handling of the historically significant collection.
- The existing library holds 8.5 lakh books, including heritage material dating back to 1702, and its permanent home is yet to be identified.
Judicial Intervention in Library Relocation
If you don't want them, give it off to some other country which will at least value them then.
The Supreme Court of India recently intervened in the planned relocation of a 135-year-old library housed within Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi. This significant intervention came as the existing building is slated for demolition as part of the broader Central Vista redevelopment project. The library, a repository of approximately 8.5 lakh books, includes invaluable heritage materials with origins tracing back to 1702.
A bench comprising Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva formally recorded an assurance from the Centre, stipulating that the Shastri Bhavan library would not be moved until the next scheduled hearing on November 20. This directive followed a critical report from the Amicus Curiae, who highlighted significant deficiencies in the proposed temporary premises and drew attention to a substantial collection of some 2 lakh books that have remained in cartons since 2011. The case, titled "In Re: 135-Yr-Old Library 8.5 Lakh Books– And No Room In The New Central Vista Plan," underscores the judiciary's close scrutiny of government projects impacting cultural assets.
Amicus Curiae's Damning Report on Preparations
The Amicus Curiae presented a detailed report to the court, outlining several critical issues regarding the planned relocation. It was revealed that a tender for shifting the library had been floated on November 11, with November 22 set as the deadline for the process. Furthermore, an affidavit from the authorities indicated an intention to move the books to a temporary location by November 26. An applicant had already urged the court to intervene, expressing concerns about the inadequacy of space at the proposed temporary site.
The Amicus Curiae's personal inspection confirmed these apprehensions. While the current Shastri Bhavan library occupies approximately 4,100 square meters, the proposed temporary premises measure only about 3,800 square meters. Crucially, the usable space at the new location is considerably less, as significant portions are taken up by corridors, lift lobbies, and other essential facilities. The Amicus requested a comprehensive comparative breakdown of the space allocated for bookshelves, racks, and reading areas versus the proposed temporary arrangement, noting that two charts provided by authorities failed to offer the necessary direct comparison of actual library space. Further details, including layout plans and a proper assessment of the proposed temporary location, were also sought.
The Amicus Curiae also brought to the court's attention the alarming state of nearly 2 lakh books stored in cartons near the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) office. Photographs presented to the bench showed these books had been in this condition since 2011, with some cartons still unopened and books scattered. The Amicus questioned why authorities had not verified or cataloged this collection, emphasizing its status as a vital part of the nation's heritage, not merely a collection of books.
Court's Emphasis on Heritage and Due Diligence
Justice Kumar expressed strong displeasure regarding the authorities' handling of the collection, remarking, "If you don't want them, give it off to some other country which will at least value them then." This pointed comment highlighted the court's concern over the perceived lack of care for such a historically significant asset. The court also questioned the authorities on the fate of the uncataloged books, the overall execution of the relocation exercise, and their approach to preserving the collection.
A broader concern voiced during the hearing was the apparent ad hoc approach adopted by the authorities towards a collection of immense historical significance. In response, Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Aishwarya Bhati, representing the Centre, attempted to differentiate the books near the CAG office from the Shastri Bhavan library collection. She clarified that these specific books belonged to the Tulsi Sadan Library and had been relocated from the National School of Drama premises at Copernicus Marg, Mandi House. Despite this clarification, the India Supreme Court library assurance remains a critical development, underscoring the judiciary's role in ensuring proper planning and preservation during large-scale urban redevelopment projects like Central Vista.
Practical Implications
This Supreme Court intervention highlights judicial scrutiny over government redevelopment projects, particularly concerning the preservation of cultural heritage and proper procedural planning for asset relocation. Lawyers advising on large-scale infrastructure or urban planning projects should note the court's emphasis on due diligence and adequate provisions for public assets, potentially setting a precedent for similar challenges.
Source
Source: Original reporting via Live Law
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in India
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
