10th Circuit: Considers Utah Opioid Lawsuit Federal Officer Removal
Case Law

10th Circuit: Considers Utah Opioid Lawsuit Federal Officer Removal

United States·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • Utah has filed a public nuisance and consumer sales practice lawsuit against pharmacy benefit managers Express Scripts and Optum over their alleged role in the opioid crisis.
  • Express Scripts and Optum are seeking to move the case to federal court, citing their work for federal healthcare programs under the federal officer removal statute.
  • Utah explicitly disclaimed claims related to federal officer work in its complaint, but the PBMs argue this disclaimer is insufficient to prevent federal jurisdiction.
  • Chief U.S. District Judge Jill Parrish initially remanded the case to state court, a decision now being appealed to the 10th Circuit.
  • The 10th Circuit's ruling will set a precedent for jurisdictional battles involving PBMs and federal healthcare programs in opioid litigation.

The Core Dispute

The 10th Circuit's decision in this matter holds significant weight, as it will establish a precedent for how similar multi-jurisdictional lawsuits involving pharmacy benefit managers and their federal healthcare program involvement are handled, influencing strategic decisions on where such cases can be litigated.

Utah has initiated a public nuisance and consumer sales practice lawsuit against two prominent pharmacy benefit managers, Express Scripts and Optum, alleging their actions significantly contributed to the state's opioid crisis. The complaint, filed in Utah’s Third Judicial District on December 23, 2024, contends that these companies oversupplied opioids throughout the state, leading to a surge in addiction and fatalities. The state further asserts that the defendants reaped substantial profits from a national quadrupling of opioid prescriptions and a tripling of prescription drug overdose deaths among Utahns in recent years, accusing them of misusing their position as PBMs to worsen the crisis.

The central point of contention currently before the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals is not the merits of Utah's claims, but rather the appropriate venue for the litigation. Express Scripts and Optum are seeking to transfer the case from Utah state court to federal court, arguing that their involvement with federal healthcare programs provides a basis for federal jurisdiction. This jurisdictional dispute was recently debated before a three-judge panel, following a decision by Chief U.S. District Judge Jill Parrish to remand the case back to state court.

Arguments for Federal Jurisdiction

Attorneys representing Express Scripts and Optum contend that the lawsuit properly belongs in federal court under the federal officer removal statute. Their argument hinges on the fact that the PBMs provided prescription drug benefits to federal programs for employees and veterans, and that these services were inextricably linked with the benefits they offered to private healthcare plans. Jonathan Cooper, counsel for the defendants, asserted that the state's claims challenge conduct performed indivisibly for both federal and non-federal clients, making it impossible to separate the two.

Cooper further argued that Chief U.S. District Judge Jill Parrish erred in determining that Utah’s explicit disclaimer, which sought to exclude the companies’ work as federal officers from the complaint, was sufficient to defeat federal jurisdiction. He cited the Eighth Circuit's *Griffin* decision, which posits that "no disclaimer, however worded, can sever the connection between the state’s claims and the defendant’s federal work." The defense also highlighted the difficulty of tracing which specific opioid prescriptions originated from federal versus non-federal plans once they entered and commingled within alleged illegal secondary markets.

Utah's Counterarguments and Broader Implications

Utah, through its Division of Consumer Protection, maintains that the case should remain in state court, emphasizing that its complaint deliberately excluded any claims related to the PBMs' activities as federal officers. Sarah Goldberg, representing the Utah Attorney General’s Office, used an analogy of a car company manufacturing engines for both civilian and military vehicles, suggesting that an injury from an engine malfunction in a private truck should not automatically trigger federal officer removal.

The defendants also argued that their appeal of Judge Parrish’s remand order should have triggered an an automatic stay, aligning with rulings from other appellate courts. Cooper contended that Judge Parrish’s ruling was inconsistent with precedents set by the Second, Sixth, and Eighth Circuits. The 10th Circuit's decision in this matter holds significant weight, as it will establish a precedent for how similar multi-jurisdictional lawsuits involving pharmacy benefit managers and their federal healthcare program involvement are handled, influencing strategic decisions on where such cases can be litigated. U.S. Circuit Judge Robert Bacharach, an Obama appointee, reportedly expressed some reluctance to affirm the lower court’s order during the proceedings.

Practical Implications

This case highlights a critical jurisdictional battle for lawyers representing pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) or states in opioid litigation. The 10th Circuit's decision on whether PBMs' federal healthcare program involvement allows removal to federal court, despite state disclaimers, will set a precedent for future multi-jurisdictional lawsuits and impact strategic decisions on where such cases can be litigated.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Associated Press

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.