Students for Life Action: Eighth Circuit Hears South Dakota Donor Disclosure Law Challenge
Summary
- Students for Life Action (SFLA) is challenging a South Dakota law requiring the disclosure of top five donors on political communications exceeding $100.
- SFLA argues the law is unconstitutional due to a lack of donor opt-out mechanisms, no time limit, and a low spending threshold, claiming it forces disclosure for communications unrelated to elections.
- The state of South Dakota contends SFLA lacks standing, asserting the law applies only to express advocacy, not the issue advocacy SFLA engages in.
- SFLA's lawyer highlighted that no federal court has upheld a disclosure statute with this specific combination of features, contrasting it with rulings in other circuits that included opt-out provisions.
- The Eighth Circuit case will examine the distinction between issue and express advocacy and the necessity of donor opt-out clauses in campaign finance disclosure laws.
Eighth Circuit Review of Disclosure Law
No federal court has previously upheld a disclosure statute combining these specific features, particularly the requirement to list general donors on every covered message without an "off-ramp" for contributors, coupled with criminal penalties.
Students for Life Action (SFLA), an anti-abortion nonprofit, has brought a challenge against a South Dakota statute requiring the disclosure of top donors on political communications. The organization presented its arguments to an Eighth Circuit panel on November 18, 2026, seeking to overturn a lower court's decision. The U.S. District Court for the District of South Dakota had rejected SFLA's facial challenge in August 2024 and ruled against its as-applied challenge in February 2026, finding that the organization lacked standing and that the law satisfied constitutional scrutiny.
At the core of the dispute is a South Dakota law mandating that any individual or group spending over $100 on an independent political communication concerning a candidate or ballot measure must include a disclaimer listing their five largest donors directly on the advertisement. SFLA initiated its lawsuit against the state in 2023, contending that this requirement is unconstitutional.
SFLA, which focuses on training and mobilizing anti-abortion leaders to influence public policy and elections, engages in activities such as sending text messages to voters about legislative records and mailers encouraging citizens to contact their state representatives. These communications, each costing more than $100, are central to the group's operations and its legal challenge.
Arguments Against the South Dakota Political Communications Law
The nonprofit asserts that the South Dakota donor disclosure law suffers from fundamental structural flaws that render it unconstitutional. Key among these alleged defects are the absence of a time limit for disclosure, a negligible $100 spending trigger, and, critically, no mechanism for donors to opt out by designating their contributions away from election-related expenditures. SFLA's legal counsel, Jeffrey M. Schwab of Liberty Justice Center, highlighted that no federal court has previously upheld a disclosure statute combining these specific features, particularly the requirement to list general donors on every covered message without an "off-ramp" for contributors, coupled with criminal penalties.
Schwab further argued that upholding this statute would require the Eighth Circuit to diverge from the reasoning of other circuits, such as the First and Tenth, which have upheld similar laws only when they included provisions allowing donors to opt out. SFLA maintains that its communications constitute issue advocacy, not express advocacy, as they encourage actions like signing petitions, urging pro-life pledges, or contacting politicians about pending legislation, rather than explicitly instructing recipients on how to vote. This distinction is crucial to their claim that the law's reach is overly broad.
State's Defense and Legal Context
South Dakota, represented by Assistant Attorney General Grant M. Flynn, countered SFLA's arguments by asserting that the district court correctly determined the student group lacked standing because the challenged law does not apply to its activities. The state contends that SFLA's claims of overbreadth and vagueness stem from a misinterpretation of the statute, arguing that its application is limited to express advocacy, which directly urges a vote for or against a candidate or measure, rather than issue advocacy.
Flynn emphasized that while SFLA points to the unique combination of features in the South Dakota law, the organization has not presented any cases where a court has struck down a statute solely because it lacked one of these particular components. This legal debate underscores a significant point of contention in campaign finance law: the precise boundary between issue advocacy, which discusses public matters, and express advocacy, which explicitly endorses or opposes political candidates, and how donor disclosure requirements apply to each.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising non-profits or political action committees (PACs) in South Dakota should monitor this Eighth Circuit case for potential changes in donor disclosure obligations, particularly regarding the distinction between issue and express advocacy, and the necessity of donor opt-out mechanisms. The ruling could impact compliance strategies for political communications and donor relations.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
