New York Times: Scalia Heller Dangerous Unusual Misquote Challenged
Legal News

New York Times: Scalia Heller Dangerous Unusual Misquote Challenged

United States·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • A recent New York Times report claims Justice Scalia's *District of Columbia v. Heller* opinion relies on a historical assertion that misquotes its source.
  • Scalia's opinion stated that traditional firearm restrictions applied only to weapons that were "dangerous and unusual," a phrase frequently used by courts to invalidate gun laws.
  • The Times highlighted that William Blackstone, the cited authority, actually wrote about weapons being "dangerous *or* unusual."
  • Conservative critics argued that Scalia's use of a "See" signal meant he was not directly quoting Blackstone, but rather referencing supporting material.
  • Despite the technical meaning of "See," the cited source does not support the proposition that only "dangerous and unusual" weapons could be regulated.

The Heller Citation Under Scrutiny

Despite the technicality of the "See" signal, the source material, in this instance, "absolutely does not" endorse the idea that only "dangerous and unusual" weapons could be regulated.

A recent report from The New York Times has brought into question a foundational element of the Supreme Court's Second Amendment jurisprudence. The article specifically focused on Justice Antonin Scalia's majority opinion in the landmark 2008 case, *District of Columbia v. Heller*, which affirmed an individual's right to possess firearms for traditionally lawful purposes. At the heart of the Times' critique was a historical assertion made by Justice Scalia, which claimed that traditional restrictions on firearms were historically limited to those weapons considered both "dangerous and unusual."

This particular phrasing, presented as a historical insight, has since been widely adopted by lower courts across the United States. These courts have frequently relied on Scalia's formulation of the "dangerous and unusual" test to invalidate various gun control measures, thereby significantly shaping the landscape of gun law enforcement. The Times' central contention was that this pivotal language, which has served as a basis for striking down numerous regulations, constituted a "misquote" of its purported historical source, sparking the "Scalia Heller dangerous unusual misquote" debate.

Unpacking the 'Dangerous and Unusual' Debate

The core of the controversy centers on a specific citation within the *Heller* opinion. Justice Scalia's text included the phrase "dangerous and unusual" in quotation marks, immediately preceding a reference to the renowned legal scholar William Blackstone. However, a closer examination of Blackstone's actual writings reveals a subtle yet significant distinction: Blackstone permitted the regulation of weapons that were "dangerous *or* unusual," rather than requiring both conditions to be met simultaneously. This discrepancy ignited the recent "Scalia citation controversy."

The Times' report provoked a strong reaction from conservative commentators, who swiftly defended Justice Scalia's citation. Jonathan Adler, writing for the Volokh Conspiracy, characterized the Times' reporting as "stunning," while Cam Edwards of Bearing Arms labeled it "journalistic malpractice." Their defense hinged on the legal citation signal "See" that preceded the Blackstone reference in *Heller*. They argued that the presence of "See" indicated that Scalia was not providing a direct, verbatim quotation, but rather pointing to a source that generally supported the proposition, even if not using identical language.

Implications for Second Amendment Jurisprudence

In legal citation conventions, the use of a "See" signal indeed clarifies that the subsequent source is not a direct quote. It signifies that the cited material supports the preceding statement or proposition, even if not using the exact words. Therefore, the technical argument that Scalia did not "misquote" in the strictest sense, given the "See" signal, holds some weight within the rules of legal scholarship. This nuance is crucial for understanding the "Scalia Heller dangerous unusual misquote" discussion.

Nevertheless, the deeper issue, and a key point in the ongoing "Scalia citation controversy," remains whether the cited work genuinely supports the proposition as stated. Despite the technicality of the "See" signal, the source material, in this instance, "absolutely does not" endorse the idea that only "dangerous and unusual" weapons could be regulated. This discrepancy could have significant ramifications for future Second Amendment jurisprudence, as lawyers litigating these cases may leverage this critique to challenge or defend gun control regulations by questioning the precedent's historical foundation. The debate over the historical accuracy of Justice Scalia's 'dangerous and unusual' test in *Heller* continues to be a critical point of contention, impacting the interpretation of the Second Amendment.

Practical Implications

Lawyers litigating Second Amendment cases should be aware of the ongoing debate regarding the historical accuracy of Justice Scalia's 'dangerous and unusual' test in *Heller*, as this critique may be leveraged to challenge or defend gun control regulations by questioning the precedent's historical foundation.

Source

Source: Original reporting via The New York Times.

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.