
National Marine Fisheries Service: Gray Whale ESA Lawsuit Challenges Protection Delay
Summary
- Environmental groups have sued the National Marine Fisheries Service for allegedly violating the Endangered Species Act.
- The lawsuit claims the agency failed to decide on a petition to protect the Eastern North Pacific gray whale, despite a significant population decline.
- Hundreds of gray whales have died along the North American west coast this year, following an "unusual mortality event" declared in 2019.
- Causes for the decline include malnourishment from Arctic warming, ship collisions, and entanglement in fishing gear.
- Plaintiffs seek a court order to compel the agency to take final action, warning that the species could be lost within a decade without intervention.
Legal Challenge to Protect Gray Whales
This legal challenge underscores the critical role of the Endangered Species Act in compelling federal agencies to address the threats facing vulnerable species, particularly when agency inaction is perceived.
A coalition of environmental organizations has initiated legal proceedings against the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), alleging a failure to uphold its responsibilities under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The lawsuit, brought by Earth Island Institute, Oasis Earth, and the Center for Biological Diversity, contends that the federal agency neglected to issue a required decision following a petition to extend protections to the Eastern North Pacific gray whale. This petition was originally submitted last year, with an initial finding anticipated from NMFS by last November.
Mark J. Palmer, associate director of the International Marine Mammal Project of Earth Island Institute, underscored the immediate necessity for governmental intervention to safeguard these marine mammals. The legal action comes amidst a concerning surge in gray whale fatalities along the North American west coast, highlighting the urgency of the species' plight and the perceived inaction by federal authorities.
Alarming Population Decline and Mortality Events
The Eastern North Pacific gray whale population has experienced a drastic decline, estimated at approximately 50% over the past decade. In 2016, the population stood at an estimated 26,960 whales, but projections indicate a drop to between 11,700 and 14,200 whales by 2025. This year alone, the National Marine Fisheries Service documented 192 dead Eastern North Pacific gray whales along the coastline stretching from Mexico to Alaska, though the actual number is believed to be higher due to unobserved or unreported incidents.
These recent deaths include 31 gray whales found along the Washington coast and 27 stranded in Alaska. The current situation follows an "unusual mortality event" declared by NMFS in 2019, which saw 216 gray whale deaths. Identified factors contributing to this decline include malnourishment linked to Arctic warming, collisions with vessels—accounting for at least 14 deaths this year from blunt force trauma—and entanglement in fishing gear, which affected at least three whales recently. Plaintiffs also point to record-low calf production as a significant concern. Miyoko Sakashita, oceans director at the Center for Biological Diversity, emphasized the staggering number of whale deaths and the administration's obligation to act.
Mandates of the Endangered Species Act
The plaintiffs assert that scientific evidence unequivocally demonstrates the endangered status of the Eastern North Pacific gray whale, a species known for its impressive annual migrations and ability to reach lengths of up to 49 feet. They argue that federal law, specifically the Endangered Species Act, clearly mandates the listing and protection of such species. Rick Steiner, founder of Oasis Earth, criticized the administration for its alleged failure to adhere to legal requirements, stating that judicial intervention is now necessary to compel the government to fulfill its statutory duties.
Historically, the species received protection from the International Whaling Convention in 1946 and was listed under the Endangered Species Act from 1970 to 1994, experiencing a temporary population rebound after its delisting. The environmental groups contend that the current dramatic population decrease, coupled with low calf production, frequent strandings, and documented mortalities from human-related causes, confirms that the gray whales are either endangered or highly likely to become so in the foreseeable future.
Implications of Agency Inaction
The lawsuit seeks a federal court declaration that the National Marine Fisheries Service has violated the Endangered Species Act, alongside an order compelling the agency to take definitive action on the petition for protection. Mark J. Palmer cautioned that despite the gray whales' historical capacity to recover from 19th and 20th-century whaling, the ongoing catastrophic decline could result in the complete loss of the population within a decade if current conditions persist.
The plaintiffs underscore that without prompt and decisive action, these whales will continue to face deteriorating ocean conditions and preventable human-caused mortalities. This legal challenge underscores the critical role of the Endangered Species Act in compelling federal agencies to address the threats facing vulnerable species, particularly when agency inaction is perceived.
Practical Implications
This case illustrates the legal recourse available under the Endangered Species Act to compel federal agencies to fulfill their statutory duties regarding species protection. Lawyers advising clients in sectors impacting marine ecosystems should note the potential for increased litigation and regulatory pressure to address declining populations of protected species, and the precedent this lawsuit could set for challenging agency inaction.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
