Case Law

Fourth Circuit: Kalshi Maryland Preemption Denied, State Gambling Laws Apply

United States·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that prediction markets like Kalshi are subject to state gambling laws, aligning with two other federal appellate courts.
  • Kalshi unsuccessfully argued that the Commodity Exchange Act grants the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over its sports event contracts, which it classified as swaps.
  • The court's majority opinion, led by Judge Roger Gregory, found no clear congressional intent to preempt state gambling laws, citing the Dodd-Frank Act's stance against "gaming."
  • Judge Stephanie Thacker concurred, concluding that Kalshi's sports event contracts are not swaps subject to CFTC exclusive regulatory authority.
  • This decision means Kalshi must comply with Maryland's consumer protection standards and licensing requirements for sports betting.

What Happened

This ruling carries significant implications for the prediction market industry, clarifying that federal law does not preempt state authority to regulate prediction markets as gambling.

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals recently affirmed that prediction markets, such as Kalshi, are subject to state gambling laws, delivering another setback to the platform's efforts to operate without state oversight. This decision aligns the Fourth Circuit with two other federal appellate courts that have reached similar conclusions regarding the applicability of state regulations to these markets. The ruling specifically upheld a Maryland federal judge's prior denial of injunctive relief to Kalshi, which had sought to prevent Maryland from requiring it to obtain a license for offering sports betting contracts within the state.

Kalshi had contended that federal law, specifically the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), preempts state authority in this domain. The company argued that its sports event contracts qualify as "swaps," a type of derivative contract whose value depends on the occurrence of an event with potential financial consequences. Under this interpretation, Kalshi asserted that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) holds exclusive jurisdiction over such instruments, thereby superseding state-level regulation.

Legal Context and Preemption

Writing for the majority, U.S. Circuit Judge Roger Gregory, a George W. Bush appointee, clarified that the central question was not whether Kalshi's contracts constituted swaps, but rather whether Congress intended to preempt Maryland's long-standing police power to regulate gambling. Judge Gregory emphasized that for federal law to displace traditional state authority, Congress must demonstrate a clear and unambiguous intent to do so, a clarity he found lacking in this instance. He concluded that Congress had not clearly and manifestly intended to preempt state gambling laws through the Commodity Exchange Act preemption.

Judge Gregory further pointed to the Dodd-Frank Act as evidence supporting the court's position. This legislation explicitly prohibits the CFTC from authorizing trading in unlawful events, such as assassinations or terrorist attacks, and designates "gaming" as contrary to the public interest, thus not sanctioned under the CEA. According to Gregory, these provisions within the Dodd-Frank Act indicate that the determination of preemption does not hinge on whether event contracts are classified as swaps. He rejected Kalshi's assertion that the CFTC's federal authority over exchange trading overrides state laws addressing distinct state interests that Congress mandated the CFTC to consider under Dodd-Frank, and also dismissed the argument that state laws conflict with the CEA. Maryland's gambling law, he noted, does not dictate whether a gaming contract can be listed or traded on a Designated Contract Market (DCM)—an authority that remains with the CFTC—but instead imposes general conditions on entities choosing to offer these sports event contracts within Maryland.

Why It Matters

U.S. Circuit Judge Stephanie Thacker, a Barack Obama appointee, concurred with the ultimate judgment but offered a distinct rationale. Judge Thacker believed the preemption question should indeed turn on whether the sports event contracts are swaps. However, she concluded that these contracts are not swaps subject to the CFTC's exclusive regulatory authority, disagreeing with the notion that "the outcome of a sporting event is itself an event." Instead, she posited that, in the sports context, the "event" refers to the contest or match itself.

This ruling carries significant implications for the prediction market industry, clarifying that federal law does not preempt state authority to regulate prediction markets as gambling. Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown underscored the importance of the decision, stating that it ensures Marylanders receive essential protections that keep gambling fair and safe when platforms operate under state oversight. He affirmed that this outcome mandates Kalshi to adhere to the same consumer protection standards as all other sportsbooks serving Maryland residents, thereby reinforcing the role of state gambling laws in safeguarding consumers.

Practical Implications

This ruling clarifies that federal law does not preempt state authority to regulate prediction markets as gambling, meaning companies operating or planning to operate in this space must comply with state-specific gambling laws and licensing requirements. Lawyers advising such clients should conduct thorough state-by-state regulatory analyses and prepare for potential enforcement actions from state attorneys general.

Source

Source: Original reporting via AP and Courthouse News Service.

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.