Supreme Court: Seeks Response on MoP Judges Appointment Delay PIL
Case Law

Supreme Court: Seeks Response on MoP Judges Appointment Delay PIL

India·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 5 min read

Summary

  • The Supreme Court recently issued notice to the central government regarding an 11-year delay in finalizing the Memorandum of Procedure for judicial appointments.
  • The public interest litigation, filed by Lok Prahari, seeks a time-bound directive for the MoP's finalization.
  • The petition also demands that minutes of collegium meetings be made accessible under the Right to Information Act, 2005.
  • The delay stems from a December 2015 NJAC Constitution Bench order that directed the government to finalize the MoP in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
  • The 2015 order emphasized transparency, including publishing eligibility criteria and considering mechanisms for minuting collegium discussions.

Recent Developments

The ongoing delay in finalizing the Memorandum of Procedure has significant implications for the Indian judiciary, impacting the efficiency and public perception of judicial appointments.

The Supreme Court of India recently sought a response from the central government regarding a public interest litigation (PIL) addressing the prolonged delay in finalizing the revised Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) for judicial appointments. This crucial document, which outlines the process for selecting judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts, has remained unfinalized for nearly eleven years since a Constitution Bench first mandated its revision in December 2015. The PIL, lodged by the registered society Lok Prahari, specifically requests a time-bound directive to conclude this long-pending process.

The petition, filed as Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1214 of 2026, names the Union of India, represented by the Secretary of the Department of Justice, as the first respondent, and the Chief Justice of India, through the Supreme Court's Secretary General, as the second respondent. Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale presided over the bench that issued the notice. This development underscores persistent concerns about the efficiency and clarity of the judges appointment process transparency in India's higher judiciary.

Historical Context of the MoP

The genesis of the current situation traces back to the Supreme Court's October 16, 2015, judgment concerning the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC). Following this ruling, a Constitution Bench, through a separate order issued in December 2015, initiated a review to incorporate "additional appropriate measures" to enhance the functioning of the collegium system. Hearings on this matter commenced on November 3, 2015. During these proceedings, then Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi advised against judicial intervention in drafting the MoP, asserting that its formulation fell within the executive's administrative domain, an area where the Court lacked the necessary expertise or resources.

The Constitution Bench ultimately concurred with this perspective. Consequently, its December 16, 2015, order directed the Government of India to finalize the existing Memorandum of Procedure by supplementing it. This finalization was to occur in consultation with the Chief Justice of India, who, in turn, was to base decisions on the unanimous consensus of the collegium, comprising the four most senior puisne judges of the Supreme Court. This directive established a clear framework for the Memorandum of Procedure finalisation, which has yet to be fully implemented.

Demands for Transparency

Beyond the primary demand for the Supreme Court MoP judges appointment delay resolution, the Lok Prahari PIL India also seeks a directive mandating public access to the minutes of collegium meetings at both High Court and Supreme Court levels under the Right to Information Act, 2005. This request aligns with the spirit of the 2015 Constitution Bench order, which emphasized transparency in the appointment process. That order specified that eligibility criteria and procedures should be published on the websites of the relevant courts and the Department of Justice.

Furthermore, the 2015 directive suggested that the MoP should include a mechanism for minuting discussions, including the recording of dissenting opinions within the collegium. While acknowledging the need for confidentiality, this provision aimed to balance it with the overarching requirement for judges appointment process transparency. The petitioner's call for RTI collegium minutes access directly addresses this aspect, pushing for greater openness in a process that has often been criticized for its opacity.

Why It Matters

The ongoing delay in finalizing the Memorandum of Procedure has significant implications for the Indian judiciary, impacting the efficiency and public perception of judicial appointments. The Supreme Court's decision to seek the Centre's reply on this matter highlights the judiciary's concern over the protracted nature of this administrative task. The outcome of this PIL could fundamentally reshape the framework for selecting judges, potentially introducing greater accountability and clarity into a system that has been the subject of considerable debate.

Prior to the current bench, the matter was initially heard on November 2 by Justices PS Narasimha and Alok Aradhe. Justice Narasimha recused himself from the proceedings, citing his previous involvement as an Additional Solicitor General in the NJAC proceedings. The registry was subsequently instructed to present the case to the Chief Justice for assignment to an alternative bench. This procedural detail underscores the sensitivity and historical weight attached to the issues surrounding judicial appointments and the crucial need for a finalized, transparent MoP.

Practical Implications

Lawyers should closely monitor the outcome of this PIL, as a finalisation of the MoP could significantly alter the process and transparency of judicial appointments in India. Furthermore, a ruling mandating RTI access to collegium minutes would set a crucial precedent for transparency in high-level governmental decision-making, impacting future public interest litigation and administrative law challenges.

Source

Source: Original reporting via legal news.

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in India

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.