Ontario Court of Appeal: Sanayhie v Durham Malicious Prosecution Appeal Gets New Trial
Case Law

Ontario Court of Appeal: Sanayhie v Durham Malicious Prosecution Appeal Gets New Trial

Canada·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • The Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial for a malicious prosecution claim against the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two constables.
  • The appeal stemmed from a trial where the jury delivered two inconsistent verdicts, with the second finding liability for malicious prosecution after a re-instruction.
  • The appellate court deemed both the initial and second jury verdicts 'unsafe' due to unclarity and improper influence from the trial judge's re-instruction.
  • A key issue was the trial judge's re-instruction, which included language that suggested a finding of malicious prosecution, thereby assuming an outcome.
  • The ruling emphasizes the necessity for neutral and precise jury re-instructions to avoid improperly influencing fact-finders and to prevent appellate intervention.

The Initial Proceedings

This ruling from the Ontario Court of Appeal underscores the critical importance of neutral and precise jury re-instructions, particularly when addressing potential inconsistencies in verdicts.

A significant ruling from the Ontario Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for a malicious prosecution claim, stemming from an incident where police removed a man from a Tim Hortons. The respondent, identified as Sanayhie, had initiated legal action against the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two constables, alleging wrongful arrest, excessive force, and malicious prosecution.

The case proceeded to a jury trial in January 2025. The jury's initial verdict found no liability for wrongful arrest or excessive use of force. While it also found no liability for malicious prosecution, it paradoxically fixed damages for that specific claim. Recognizing this inconsistency, the trial judge issued a re-instruction, prompting the jury to reconsider its original findings. After approximately 20 minutes of further deliberation, the jury returned with a second verdict, which reversed its previous stance on malicious prosecution, finding liability and imposing damages in the same amount as initially fixed. The appellants subsequently sought judgment based on the first verdict, which would have absolved them of malicious prosecution liability. However, on June 26, 2025, former Justice Michael K. McKelvey of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed their motion, entering judgment according to the second verdict.

Appellate Intervention and Unsafe Verdicts

The Durham Regional Police Services Board and the two constables then brought an appeal before the Ontario Court of Appeal in the case of Sanayhie v. Durham (Police Services Board), 2026 ONCA 813. The appellate court allowed the appeal, setting aside the trial judgment related to the malicious prosecution claim, including all associated damages and legal costs. The Court of Appeal characterized the initial jury verdict as both unclear and unsafe, highlighting the inherent contradiction in finding no liability but still assessing damages.

Crucially, the appeal court also deemed the second verdict unsafe. This determination was primarily due to concerns that the trial judge's re-instruction had improperly influenced the jury's decision-making process. The court specifically took issue with the inclusion of the phrase, "presumably based on the finding of a malicious prosecution," within the re-instruction, suggesting it pre-empted the jury's role as fact-finders. Justice Peter D. Lauwers, writing for the appeal court, noted that the initial jury instructions did not align with the questions presented to the jury and that the trial judge failed to adequately explain the inconsistency between his prior instruction and the verdict sheet's wording. This created a significant risk that the jury's understanding was compromised, leading to an improperly influenced outcome.

Implications for Jury Re-instruction in Canada

This ruling from the Ontario Court of Appeal underscores the critical importance of neutral and precise jury re-instructions, particularly when addressing potential inconsistencies in verdicts. Justice Lauwers emphasized that there was a tangible risk that the trial judge’s initial instructions were not fully comprehended, and his subsequent comments during re-instruction improperly swayed the jury in its fundamental role as the arbiter of facts. The decision in Sanayhie v Durham malicious prosecution appeal provides vital guidance for judges across Canada on the delicate balance required when guiding a jury through complex legal questions.

The appellate court's decision to declare both verdicts 'unsafe' highlights the stringent standards applied to jury instructions and re-instructions in Ontario. It reinforces that any judicial intervention must be carefully crafted to clarify, rather than to suggest or assume, a particular outcome. This case serves as a reminder that trial judges must adopt a more careful approach to re-instruction, ensuring that the jury's independence in determining liability, especially in intricate claims like malicious prosecution, remains uncompromised to prevent an Ontario Court Appeal unsafe verdict.

Practical Implications

This ruling provides critical guidance on the proper procedure for jury re-instruction in Ontario, highlighting the risks of appellate intervention when trial judges' comments are perceived to influence jury findings. Lawyers should carefully scrutinize jury instructions and re-instructions for clarity and neutrality to prevent verdicts from being deemed 'unsafe' on appeal, particularly in cases involving complex liability findings like malicious prosecution.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Canadian Lawyer Magazine

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Canada

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.