
OCA: Orders New Trial in Malicious Prosecution Case
The Ontario Court of Appeal (OCA), in Sanayhie v. Durham (Police Services Board), 2026 ONCA 813, recently allowed an appeal and set aside a trial judgment, ordering a new trial specifically for a malicious prosecution claim, after deeming two jury verdicts "unsafe" in a case involving allegations of wrongful arrest and excessive force against the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two constables. This decision, rendered in 2026, follows a jury trial in January 2025 where the jury initially found no liability for malicious prosecution but fixed damages, and then, after a re-instruction from the trial judge, returned a second verdict finding liability for malicious prosecution. The OCA characterized the first verdict as unclear and the second as unsafe due to the trial judge's re-instruction, which it found unnecessarily suggested a particular outcome.
This ruling is highly significant for civil litigation involving jury trials in Ontario, particularly concerning the handling of inconsistent verdicts and the scope of a trial judge's re-instruction to a jury. The OCA's decision to set aside both verdicts and order a new trial underscores the appellate court's commitment to ensuring the integrity and safety of jury findings, especially in complex tort claims against public bodies. It highlights the delicate balance a trial judge must strike when guiding a jury through deliberations without unduly influencing their decision-making process. For practitioners, this case serves as a crucial reminder of the procedural pitfalls that can arise during jury trials and the importance of meticulously scrutinizing jury instructions and verdicts for clarity and consistency. The key parties are the plaintiff, who was the respondent in the appeal, and the appellants, the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two constables, who were the defendants at trial.
The legal context of this case primarily revolves around the procedural aspects of jury trials and the substantive law of torts, specifically malicious prosecution, wrongful arrest, and excessive force, within the Canadian common law framework. The tort of malicious prosecution requires proof that the defendant initiated proceedings without reasonable and probable cause and with malice, and that the proceedings terminated in the plaintiff's favour. The OCA's intervention here focuses less on the substantive elements of these torts and more on the procedural fairness and reliability of the jury's findings. The court's assessment of the "safety" of the verdicts relates to established principles of appellate review, where a verdict may be overturned if it is unreasonable, unsupported by evidence, or if there was a miscarriage of justice due to procedural irregularities, such as an improper re-instruction. The trial judge's re-instruction, which the OCA found problematic, likely touched upon the rules governing jury deliberations and the need for consistency in their findings, as outlined in various procedural rules and case law.
Attorneys involved in jury trials, particularly those dealing with complex claims or multiple causes of action, must pay close attention to the jury's initial verdicts and any subsequent re-instructions from the bench. This case emphasizes the importance of ensuring that jury instructions are neutral, clear, and do not inadvertently steer the jury towards a particular outcome, as such actions can lead to an "unsafe" verdict and necessitate a costly new trial. Practitioners should be prepared to object to potentially problematic re-instructions and to argue for the proper interpretation of inconsistent verdicts. Furthermore, this decision reinforces the ongoing challenges in litigating claims against police services, where the interplay of factual disputes, legal standards for police conduct, and procedural fairness in court can lead to lengthy and intricate legal battles. The outcome of the new trial on the malicious prosecution claim, which is not yet reported, will be of significant interest to both plaintiffs and defendants in similar actions.
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Canada
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
