
Ninth Circuit Questions DHS Noise Regulations' Vagueness
Summary
- The Ninth Circuit is reviewing DHS regulations prohibiting "loud or unusual noise" near federal buildings, following a lower court's injunction.
- The regulations stemmed from a 2018 protest in Eugene, Oregon, where megaphones were used against Trump administration policies.
- A federal judge previously blocked the rules, citing vagueness under the Fifth Amendment's due process clause.
- Appellate judges questioned the government on officer discretion and the broad application of the noise regulations.
- The case examines the balance between government operations and First Amendment free speech rights on federal property.
Ninth Circuit Scrutinizes Noise Regulations
The Ninth Circuit's scrutiny of these federal building protest regulations underscores the importance of clear, narrowly tailored rules to avoid infringing on constitutional protections.
A federal appellate panel in the Ninth Circuit recently questioned the scope and enforceability of Department of Homeland Security (DHS) regulations that prohibit "loud or unusual noise" near federal buildings. This judicial review follows a lower court's decision earlier this year to block the enforcement of these new rules, which were introduced by the Trump administration. The government is now seeking to overturn that injunction, arguing for the necessity of such restrictions.
The regulations came under scrutiny after a 2018 protest outside a federal building in Eugene, Oregon. During this demonstration, individuals used megaphones to voice opposition to the Trump administration's family separation policy. While IRS workers were conducting taxpayer interviews inside the building, the government characterized the external noise as a disruption, whereas the protesters asserted their actions were protected free speech. This incident became a focal point in the legal challenge against the DHS noise regulations.
Vagueness Challenge and Government Arguments
The federal judge in Oregon initially found the new noise regulation to be excessively vague, violating the Fifth Amendment's due process clause. However, Department of Justice attorney Brian Springer, representing the government, contended before the three-judge Ninth Circuit panel that the provision is a common-sense measure designed to prevent disruptions to government operations, similar to internal noise restrictions. Springer asserted that such noise restrictions are long-standing and widely accepted in law.
Challenging the lower court's vagueness finding, Springer argued that numerous federal courts, including the Supreme Court and the Ninth Circuit itself, have consistently upheld similar provisions against vagueness challenges. He maintained that the language of the regulation provides sufficient notice regarding the prohibited conduct. Despite these assertions, all three judges on the panel, who are appointees of President Joe Biden, expressed skepticism, questioning the relevance of the government's cited cases in its opening brief and the imprecise wording of the "unusual noise" prohibition.
Judicial Concerns Over Discretion and Scope
The appellate judges pressed the government on the extent of discretion federal officers would possess in enforcing these DHS discretion protest rules, and how broadly the regulations might apply across different types of federal buildings. U.S. Circuit Judge Jennifer Sung presented a hypothetical scenario: if a traffic jam outside a federal building led to honking that employees inside could hear and find disruptive, would that constitute a violation? Springer responded that the noise must actively affect the building's operations.
U.S. Circuit Judge Roopali Desai pushed for a clearer answer, asking if a potential effect on operations would be sufficient for a violation, and if not, why. Springer's reply was that it "depends," and that a "fleeting honk is very unlikely to violate the regulation." Judge Sung further questioned the broad interpretation of "affect," pointing out that the regulation refers to "loud or unusual noise in areas outside of property that affects persons on the federal property." She emphasized that the regulation lacked specific language to narrow the definition of "affects" to only the types of disruptions the agency intended to target. Marianne Dugan, representing the protesters, argued that this exchange with the government attorney clearly demonstrated why the regulation was facially unconstitutional.
Implications for Free Speech and Federal Property
This case highlights the ongoing tension between safeguarding First Amendment rights, particularly Trump administration free speech concerns, and the government's interest in maintaining order and operational efficiency at federal facilities. The Ninth Circuit's scrutiny of these federal building protest regulations underscores the importance of clear, narrowly tailored rules to avoid infringing on constitutional protections.
The outcome of this appeal could set a significant precedent for how future noise restrictions are drafted and enforced on federal property. It reinforces the legal community's focus on ensuring that regulations do not grant excessive discretion to law enforcement or create vague standards that could chill legitimate protest activities, thereby impacting the balance between public order and fundamental liberties.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising clients on protest rights or government agencies drafting regulations should note the Ninth Circuit's scrutiny of DHS noise regulations for federal buildings, particularly concerns regarding vagueness and the scope of officer discretion. This case highlights the ongoing tension between maintaining order and protecting First Amendment rights, and could set precedent for future challenges to similar restrictions.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
