
BC Judge Blocks Secondary Picketing at Port Terminal
Summary
- A British Columbia Supreme Court judge issued an injunction blocking United Steelworkers Local 7619 from secondary picketing at a North Vancouver port.
- The picketing, targeting PKM Canada Services Inc.'s port terminal, was deemed likely illegal under the British Columbia Labour Relations Code.
- The court found that prior orders from labor boards were insufficient to prevent economic damage and that the port operator lacked standing to enforce them.
- Justice Simon Coval rejected union arguments that an injunction was no longer necessary, citing their stated intent to potentially resume picketing.
- PKM Canada Services Inc. and the B.C. Marine Employers’ Association are pursuing damages against the unions for economic losses incurred.
Court Blocks Secondary Picketing at BC Port
The defendants’ insistence on retaining the ability to revive the picket line with reasonable notice reflects their position that they have the right to carry out the impugned conduct.
A British Columbia Supreme Court judge has issued an injunction, preventing striking steelworkers from continuing their picketing activities at a North Vancouver port terminal. The ruling, handed down by Justice Simon Coval, sided with PKM Canada Services Inc., the port operator, which had sought to halt the expanded labor action. The United Steelworkers Local 7619 (USW), along with allied organizations, had extended its strike against Teck Resources’ Highland Valley Copper mine to PKM’s facility, leading to significant disruptions.
The lawsuit, initiated by PKM Canada Services Inc. and the B.C. Marine Employers’ Association, argued that the picketing constituted an illegal secondary picket under provincial labor laws. Attorney Ryan Copeland, representing PKM, highlighted that the refusal of longshore workers to cross the picket line resulted in substantial business interruptions over several days. Justice Coval broadly concurred with PKM's assertion that the picket had already inflicted irreversible damage and that without judicial intervention, the port faced further risks.
Legal Framework and Prior Interventions
The core of the legal challenge centered on the British Columbia Labour Relations Code, which explicitly limits picketing to a union's direct workplace. The USW's expansion of its strike against Teck Resources to the PKM port terminal, a location not directly involved in the primary dispute, was deemed likely illegal under these provincial regulations. This legal context underpinned the court's decision to grant the injunction, reinforcing the strict limitations on secondary picketing.
Prior to the court's involvement, both the Canada Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) and the B.C. Labour Relations Board (BCLRB) had issued orders related to the dispute. The CIRB had directed longshore workers to cross the picket line, while the BCLRB had issued an order barring the picket line the night before November 9. However, the picketing continued into the morning of November 9, with longshore workers reportedly ignoring the CIRB's directives. The B.C. Federation of Labour, a labor advocacy group, had also issued a "hot edict" encouraging other unionized workers not to handle materials from the mine, and various other local unions joined the picket.
Judicial Scrutiny of Union Arguments
Justice Coval rejected arguments from both the USW and the B.C. Federation of Labour that the existing orders from the BCLRB and CIRB were sufficient to manage the situation. He noted that the federal labor board lacked the authority to directly order the steelworkers not to picket the port location, though it could compel longshore workers to cross the line. Furthermore, PKM Canada Services Inc. itself did not possess the standing to enforce or maintain the provincial labor board's orders against the picketing. The judge also pointed out that the BCLRB order could be modified or terminated at any time, echoing concerns that PKM's operational stability remained vulnerable to Teck's decisions regarding the order's enforcement.
A key point of contention for Justice Coval was whether an injunction remained necessary, especially after union lawyers stated that no picketing had occurred at the terminal for a week leading up to the Monday hearing. The union representatives, including Chris Buchanan for the B.C. Federation of Labour and William Clements for USW, indicated they did not anticipate returning to the terminal and were willing to agree not to do so without reasonable notice to PKM. However, Coval remained unconvinced, citing the continued picketing even after the initial labor board orders. He emphasized that "The defendants’ insistence on retaining the ability to revive the picket line with reasonable notice reflects their position that they have the right to carry out the impugned conduct." PKM and the B.C. Marine Employers’ Association are still pursuing damages from USW and the B.C. Federation of Labour for the economic impact, with arguments for this to be heard at a later, unspecified date.
Practical Implications
This ruling reinforces the strict limitations on secondary picketing under British Columbia's Labour Relations Code, demonstrating that courts will grant injunctive relief to prevent illegal picketing even if labor board orders have been issued. Lawyers advising businesses or unions in BC should note the judiciary's willingness to intervene to prevent economic damage from expanded picketing, emphasizing the need for strict compliance with picketing location rules.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
