US Court: NIH Grant Applications Face Viewpoint Discrimination Challenge
Case Law

US Court: NIH Grant Applications Face Viewpoint Discrimination Challenge

United States·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • Researchers are challenging the National Institutes of Health over an algorithmic screening process for grant applications.
  • This process reportedly flags over 200 "disfavored terms," potentially leading to funding termination if not removed.
  • Plaintiffs argue this constitutes viewpoint discrimination and violates their First Amendment rights.
  • U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria is tentatively inclined to find that grant terminations violate the First Amendment under the *Thakur v. Trump* precedent.
  • The Department of Justice contends current NIH policies do not discriminate by viewpoint but focus on scientific merit.

What Happened

This National Institutes of Health grant challenge highlights a critical tension between governmental policy objectives and First Amendment research funding protections, with the judge's final decision poised to shape the future landscape of federal support for scientific inquiry.

A legal challenge has emerged against the National Institutes of Health (NIH) regarding its grant application process, with researchers alleging that an algorithmic screening system unfairly targets certain viewpoints. This system reportedly scans applications for over 200 "disfavored terms," including phrases such as "gender," "diverse," and "climate change." Should these flagged terms remain in an application without being replaced by what are termed "preferred phrasing," the researchers contend that their funding could face termination, an action they argue constitutes a violation of their First Amendment rights.

The plaintiffs have formally requested that a U.S. District Judge issue an order to prevent the government from enforcing these policies, which they characterize as a political viewpoint screen. Additionally, they are seeking to certify two distinct nationwide classes of researchers who are challenging these practices. Representing the researchers, Vera Eidelman, a senior staff attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union, articulated that the government, unlike a private entity, is bound by the First Amendment. She emphasized that while the government is not initially obligated to fund private speech, once it does, it is prohibited from discriminating based on viewpoint or imposing unreasonable restrictions within that forum.

Legal Context

During the proceedings, U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria acknowledged the existence of a First Amendment concern regarding the government's practice of scrutinizing the specific language researchers employ to describe their work. However, Judge Chhabria initially expressed skepticism about the argument that terminating grants based on an administration's policy preferences would also infringe upon constitutional rights. His tentative view suggested that the executive branch possesses the authority to make policy-driven decisions concerning which research projects receive funding.

Despite this initial inclination, Judge Chhabria conceded that his personal belief might ultimately be superseded by the controlling precedent established in *Thakur v. Trump*. In that case, a federal judge determined that the government's cancellation of research grants, particularly for reasons related to diversity, equity, and inclusion, likely violated the First Amendment. This ruling led to a preliminary injunction that vacated the federal agencies' terminations of the class members' grants, a decision the Ninth Circuit subsequently upheld by denying the government's request for a stay, and which the Supreme Court later declined to review. Judge Chhabria specifically referenced a hypothetical scenario involving the cancellation of a grant studying structural racism's impact on kidney disease, noting that while he might tentatively view it as not a First Amendment violation, it "pretty clearly is under Thakur."

Why It Matters

The ongoing HHS grant screening lawsuit holds significant implications for federal research funding, particularly concerning NIH grant applications viewpoint discrimination. Judge Chhabria has indicated a tentative inclination to rule that the grant terminations in question violate the First Amendment, drawing directly from the *Thakur v. Trump* precedent. This would likely lead to the certification of a class of researchers whose projects were terminated. Furthermore, the judge is tentatively inclined to find that the challenged policies themselves violate both the *Thakur* precedent and the Administrative Procedure Act.

Conversely, the Department of Justice, represented by Jordan Hulseberg, has conceded that some past grant terminations are indeed unconstitutional under *Thakur*. However, Hulseberg argued that the *Thakur* precedent does not apply to the NIH's current policies. The DOJ's position is that the current guidelines do not discriminate based on viewpoint but instead focus on criteria for "what makes good science, good science," asserting that "Right now, we don’t believe that there are First Amendment problems with the current operative guidance." This National Institutes of Health grant challenge highlights a critical tension between governmental policy objectives and First Amendment research funding protections, with the judge's final decision poised to shape the future landscape of federal support for scientific inquiry.

Practical Implications

Lawyers advising research institutions or grant applicants should monitor this case for developments regarding First Amendment protections against viewpoint discrimination in federal funding decisions, particularly in light of the *Thakur v. Trump* precedent. Compliance officers should assess internal policies for grant application preparation and termination responses to ensure alignment with evolving legal standards on government funding and free speech.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Associated Press

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.