Foster v. Canada CHRA s. 42(2): Federal Court Reviews CHRC Complaint Decline
Case Law

Foster v. Canada CHRA s. 42(2): Federal Court Reviews CHRC Complaint Decline

Canada·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • A former CSC employee's discrimination complaint was declined by the CHRC after his paralegal advised him to withdraw grievances.
  • The Federal Court found the CHRC unreasonably applied section 42(2) of the Canadian Human Rights Act.
  • The court ruled that the CHRC must consider the actions of all representatives, including paralegals, when attributing responsibility for failing to exhaust grievance processes.
  • The CHRC's decision was set aside and returned for reconsideration, with the applicant awarded $2500 in costs.

Background of the Complaint

The Federal Court concluded that it was not reasonable for the Commission to only consider whether the failure to exhaust the grievance process was attributable to the union, without also assessing the role of the paralegal.

A former employee of Correctional Service Canada (CSC), who had served for approximately 27 years, faced termination on November 21, 2017, following a period of personal difficulties that began impacting his work performance in 2015. CSC initiated an internal investigation into his conduct in May 2016 and subsequently attempted, without success, to conduct a disciplinary interview in the months that followed his initial performance issues.

Following his termination, the applicant's union filed two grievances on his behalf with the Federal Public Sector Labour Relations and Employment Board on December 14, 2017. Concurrently, in 2018, the applicant lodged a disability and racial discrimination complaint with the Canadian Human Rights Commission (CHRC) to ensure the one-year limitation period was preserved. The CHRC notified the applicant on November 22, 2018, that it might decline to process his complaint under section 41(1)(a) of the Canadian Human Rights Act, 1985 (CHRA), citing the non-exhaustion of the available grievance process.

Paralegal Involvement and CHRC's Decision

Frustrated by the protracted grievance process, the applicant engaged a licensed paralegal in March 2022. The paralegal advised him to withdraw from the ongoing grievance proceedings and instead focus solely on the CHRC complaint. Acting on this advice, the applicant requested his union to withdraw the grievances, which led to the cancellation of scheduled hearings.

Subsequently, the paralegal attempted to reactivate the 2018 human rights complaint with the CHRC. However, on March 19, 2025, the CHRC formally declined to deal with the complaint under section 41(1)(a) of the CHRA. This decision was based on the discontinuance of the grievance process and the resulting non-exhaustion of the adjudication process, prompting the applicant to seek judicial review of the CHRC's determination.

Federal Court's Ruling on CHRA s. 42(2)

The applicant initiated a judicial review application, arguing that the CHRC's decision was unreasonable and alleging incompetence on the part of his paralegal. The Federal Court, in Foster v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FC 1401, ultimately granted the judicial review application, setting aside the CHRC's decision and remitting the matter back to the Commission for reconsideration. The court also awarded the applicant $2500 in agreed costs.

Justice Michael Battista, writing for the court, determined that the CHRC had unreasonably applied section 42(2) of the CHRA. This specific provision requires the CHRC to ascertain whether the failure to exhaust a grievance process is attributable to the applicant or to 'another' party. The court noted that the CHRC's own human rights officer's report acknowledged that both the union and a paralegal represented the applicant. The Federal Court concluded that it was not reasonable for the Commission to only consider whether the failure to exhaust the grievance process was attributable to the union, without also assessing the role of the paralegal.

Implications for CHRC Proceedings

The Federal Court clarified that the term 'another' within section 42(2) of the Canadian Human Rights Act can encompass more than just an applicant's bargaining agent, extending to other representatives such as paralegals. This interpretation underscores that the CHRC must consider the actions of all representatives when determining the attribution of responsibility for procedural failures, particularly concerning the exhaustion of grievance processes.

Given the misapplication of this critical statutory consideration, the court found it unnecessary to delve into the applicant's claims regarding ineffective counsel. This ruling, concerning Foster v. Canada CHRA s. 42(2), highlights the importance of a comprehensive assessment by the CHRC of all parties involved in an applicant's representation when evaluating compliance with procedural requirements, ensuring that an unreasonable CHRC decision can be challenged through judicial review.

Practical Implications

Lawyers representing clients before the Canadian Human Rights Commission (CHRC) should note that the Federal Court will scrutinize the CHRC's application of CHRA s. 42(2) regarding the attribution of responsibility for failing to exhaust grievance processes. This case clarifies that the CHRC must consider the actions of *all* representatives, including paralegals, not just the applicant or their union, when determining if a procedural failure is attributable to 'another' party, providing grounds for judicial review if this is not adequately done.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Canadian Lawyer magazine

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Canada

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.