
Delaware Court of Chancery: Imposes AI Sanctions for Fabricated Citations
Summary
- On November 13, 2026, the Delaware Court of Chancery sanctioned a lawyer for submitting a brief containing AI-hallucinated citations and mischaracterized legal authorities.
- The lawyer's firm was exonerated from joint liability under Delaware Rule 11, as it demonstrated "exceptional circumstances" through its robust AI policies.
- The firm had banned unapproved generative AI tools, formed a working group, adopted a comprehensive AI policy requiring lawyer review, and implemented training on AI hallucinations.
- The court cited the Delaware Lawyers' Rules of Professional Conduct and ABA Formal Opinion 512, emphasizing firm leadership's responsibility for ethical compliance in AI use.
- This ruling highlights the critical importance for law firms to establish clear, proactive guidelines and training programs for artificial intelligence to mitigate professional conduct risks.
The Sanctioned Attorney's Misconduct
The court ultimately determined that the firm's proactive and comprehensive approach constituted 'exceptional circumstances,' thereby relieving it of joint responsibility for the attorney's misconduct.
On November 13, 2026, the Delaware Court of Chancery issued a significant order imposing sanctions on an attorney for professional misconduct involving artificial intelligence. The lawyer had submitted a brief that included fabricated quotations and mischaracterized legal authorities, a serious breach of professional standards. This issue came to light after the opposing counsel identified the discrepancies.
Following the exposure, the attorney filed a "corrected" brief. However, this revised submission merely removed the quotation marks from the original hallucinated citations while retaining the inaccurate legal propositions, failing to rectify the underlying falsehoods. The lawyer attempted to shift blame, first attributing the errors to a paralegal, and then criticizing the opposing side for not engaging in a "meet and confer" discussion before alerting the court.
The court unequivocally rejected these defenses. It stated that "There is nothing to negotiate or compromise when an attorney submits false citations to a tribunal," underscoring the gravity of presenting false information to the judiciary. Despite this, the attorney persistently maintained that the cited authorities were "real" and fully supported the arguments presented in the brief, even in the face of clear evidence to the contrary.
Court's Ruling and Legal Framework
The Delaware Court of Chancery ultimately sanctioned the attorney under Delaware's version of Rule 11, a rule designed to prevent frivolous filings and ensure the veracity of submissions to the court. This rule, which mirrors its federal counterpart, includes a crucial provision regarding firm responsibility: "absent exceptional circumstances, a law firm must be held jointly responsible for a violation committed by its partner, associate, or employee." This clause placed the attorney's firm under scrutiny for potential joint liability, particularly concerning Delaware Rule 11 AI sanctions.
In its deliberation, the court also referenced the Delaware Lawyers' Rules of Professional Conduct, which explicitly require law firm leadership to undertake reasonable efforts to ensure compliance with ethical rules by all firm members. Furthermore, the court cited ABA Formal Opinion 512, an influential guidance document that specifically calls upon law firms to establish clear and comprehensive policies governing the permissible use of artificial intelligence tools. These legal and ethical frameworks provided the backdrop against which the firm's actions were evaluated.
The Firm's Exoneration and Proactive Measures
Crucially, the court found that the law firm in question had demonstrated "exceptional circumstances" that warranted its exoneration from joint responsibility for its attorney's misconduct. The court ultimately determined that the firm's proactive and comprehensive approach constituted 'exceptional circumstances,' thereby relieving it of joint responsibility for the attorney's misconduct. This decision highlights the critical importance of a robust law firm AI policy liability framework, as the firm had undertaken "substantial institutional efforts to prevent the very problem at issue."
The firm's preventative measures were detailed and timely. In March 2023, it implemented an initial ban on the use of unapproved generative AI tools. By 2024, recognizing the evolving landscape of legal technology, the firm established a dedicated working group tasked with evaluating various generative AI tools and thoroughly studying the ethical guidance surrounding their application. This culminated in July 2025 with the adoption of a comprehensive generative AI policy. This policy mandated that an experienced lawyer must review all generative AI output for both accuracy and completeness before its use. Beyond policy implementation, the firm further developed an internal training program specifically designed to educate its legal professionals on the phenomenon of AI hallucinations and how to mitigate their risks, thereby addressing lawyers professional conduct AI concerns directly.
Practical Implications
Law firms should immediately review and implement comprehensive AI use policies and training programs, as demonstrated by the Delaware Court of Chancery's decision to exonerate a firm from joint liability due to its robust AI guidelines, which served as 'exceptional circumstances' under Rule 11.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
