
Amazon Perplexity AI Comet Lawsuit: Judge Stays Discovery, Weighs Dismissal
Summary
- Amazon is suing Perplexity AI, alleging its Comet tool accesses Amazon without authorization.
- The case recently returned to Senior U.S. District Judge Maxine Chesney, who granted a stay on discovery to consider a dismissal motion.
- The Ninth Circuit previously overturned Judge Chesney's initial ruling, stating that the user, not the AI tool, accesses Amazon's computers.
- Amazon argues new facts, including a new Comet version and employee testing, and that the AI tool can act independently.
- Perplexity AI maintains that the user always directs the agent and must grant account access, aligning with the Ninth Circuit's prior decision.
What Happened
The central question of what constitutes "unauthorized access" under the CFAA remains a critical point of contention.
Amazon is currently pursuing a lawsuit against Perplexity AI, alleging that its Comet tool accesses the online retail giant's platform without proper authorization. The legal dispute recently returned to Senior U.S. District Judge Maxine Chesney, who openly expressed her uncertainty regarding the appropriate path forward for the case. During a three-hour hearing, Judge Chesney ultimately granted Perplexity's request for a stay in discovery proceedings, a move intended to mitigate costs while she considers a motion for dismissal. This decision marks a significant procedural development in the ongoing Amazon Perplexity AI Comet lawsuit, which centers on the interaction between artificial intelligence agents and established online services.
Legal Context and Prior Rulings
The core of Amazon's complaint against Perplexity AI involves claims that the Comet tool, an AI web browser capable of performing tasks like price and review comparisons on Amazon, violates federal and state statutes. Specifically, Amazon cites the U.S. Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) and the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (CCDAFA). Judge Chesney had initially indicated that Amazon was likely to succeed on these arguments. However, a Ninth Circuit panel subsequently reversed her findings, concluding that her analysis of what constitutes access "without authorization" or "exceeding authorized access" was flawed. The Ninth Circuit Comet ruling established that it is the human user who initiates access to Amazon's computers with the aid of the AI assistant, not the AI tool itself. This same logic led to the failure of Amazon's claim under the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act, sending the case back to the district court.
Shifting Arguments in Court
Upon the case's return, Judge Chesney sought clarification from both parties on how to apply the Ninth Circuit's directive. Hagan Scotten, representing Amazon, introduced what he described as new facts not considered by the appellate court. He highlighted the release of a new version of Comet since the Ninth Circuit's decision and asserted that Perplexity employees had tested earlier versions of the AI tool on Amazon. Scotten further argued that the appellate panel had misunderstood Comet's operational mechanics, mistakenly believing it only acted when explicitly directed by a user. He contended that a user could simply ask Comet to purchase an item, and the tool would then proceed to Amazon independently, without being explicitly 'invited in.' Scotten characterized Perplexity as a 'rogue actor' violating Amazon's restrictions on AI tools, asserting that Perplexity, and Perplexity alone, controls the agent's actions on Amazon.
Conversely, Daniel Posner, counsel for Perplexity AI, challenged Amazon's assertion of new facts, arguing that the situation had not fundamentally changed since the Ninth Circuit's ruling. Posner maintained that Comet cannot access Amazon directly; instead, a user must grant the AI assistant access to their personal Amazon account. He emphasized that the user consistently directs the agent's actions, which forms the basis of the Ninth Circuit's decision. Posner suggested that Amazon's claims regarding employee access were a desperate attempt to salvage its case, arguing that criminalizing such conduct would directly contradict the appellate court's opinion. While acknowledging Scotten's persuasive arguments, Judge Chesney expressed her intent to proceed with extreme caution to avoid another reversal of her decision.
Implications for AI and Online Access
The ongoing legal dispute between Amazon v Perplexity AI carries substantial implications for the future development and deployment of artificial intelligence tools, particularly those designed to interact with third-party online platforms. The central question of what constitutes "unauthorized access" under the CFAA remains a critical point of contention. The ultimate outcome of this case, especially how the court interprets the agency and control dynamics between AI agents and human users, will significantly influence the legal boundaries for AI web browser scraping and other automated interactions with online services. This case serves as a crucial watchpoint for technology companies and legal professionals advising on AI development, as it could redefine liability for circumventing terms of service or accessing data through automated means.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising tech companies developing AI tools, particularly those interacting with third-party platforms, must closely monitor this case for evolving interpretations of 'unauthorized access' under the CFAA. The outcome will significantly influence the legal boundaries for AI agents interacting with online services and potential liability for data scraping or circumventing terms of service.
Source
Source: Original reporting via AP News
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
