
ASIC Sues Commonwealth Bank: CommBiz Fees Overcharged 42,000 Customers
Summary
- ASIC has initiated civil penalty proceedings against Commonwealth Bank for allegedly overcharging 42,000 business customers $8.5 million on its CommBiz platform.
- The regulator claims CBA failed to disclose "contra leg" fees for Direct Debit and Direct Credit payments, leading to misleading conduct.
- ASIC alleges the overcharging occurred for approximately 19 years, despite customer complaints from 2015 and an internal audit in 2016.
- CBA has since stopped charging the fees, amended its terms, and paid over $26.4 million in remediation to 93,000 customers.
- ASIC is seeking declarations, pecuniary penalties, adverse publicity orders, and costs from the court.
What Happened
Commissioner Alan Kirkland emphasized that the alleged conduct represents a fundamental failure by the bank to 'get the basics right over many years,' asserting that CBA breached a core promise to its business clients, many of whom are small businesses, that the fees disclosed would be the fees actually charged.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has initiated civil penalty proceedings against the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), alleging that the financial institution imposed undisclosed fees on approximately 42,000 business customers using its CommBiz platform. The regulator claims these charges amounted to $8.5 million in overpayments. The core of the complaint revolves around the bank's alleged failure to transparently communicate additional fees associated with Direct Debit and Direct Credit transactions, leading to what ASIC describes as misleading conduct.
The CommBiz platform, designed for business banking, typically charges for payments involving third-party accounts. However, ASIC's investigation uncovered that CBA also levied additional, unstated fees for corresponding transfers into or out of the customers' *own* accounts. These specific charges are referred to as "contra leg" fees. An illustrative example provided by ASIC highlights how a small business processing fortnightly wages for ten employees from two CommBiz accounts would effectively be charged for twelve transactions instead of ten, due to two hidden charges for withdrawals from its own accounts. This practice forms the basis of the ASIC civil penalty proceedings CBA.
Regulatory Allegations and Duration
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission asserts that the Commonwealth Bank CommBiz overcharging persisted for approximately 19 years, dating back to the launch of the CommBiz platform in 2006. ASIC's allegations extend beyond mere overcharging, encompassing claims of significant governance failures within CBA. The regulator states that the bank received customer complaints regarding these fees as early as 2015, and an internal audit conducted in 2016 specifically identified the overcharging issue, recommending corrective actions.
Despite these internal warnings and customer feedback, ASIC contends that CBA's internal controls and governance structures were inadequate, preventing the bank from identifying and rectifying the misleading statements and practices. Commissioner Alan Kirkland emphasized that the alleged conduct represents a fundamental failure by the bank to 'get the basics right over many years,' asserting that CBA breached a core promise to its business clients, many of whom are small businesses, that the fees disclosed would be the fees actually charged. This highlights ASIC's focus on long-standing governance failures. The regulator further alleges that CBA failed to act efficiently, honestly, and fairly in its dealings with customers, particularly concerning these undisclosed banking fees Australia.
Bank's Response and Remediation Efforts
In response to the issues, CBA took several steps to address the fee structure and customer impact. The bank temporarily ceased charging the contentious fees in June 2025 and subsequently updated its CommBiz terms and conditions in August 2025 to reflect clearer disclosures. Since February 2026, CBA has permanently waived the relevant fees for its business customers. These actions followed a period where the alleged CommBiz contra leg fees continued to be applied.
Beyond altering its fee practices, CBA has also undertaken a comprehensive remediation program. This initiative covered the period from December 2006 onwards, resulting in the repayment of over $26.4 million to approximately 93,000 customers. This substantial group included 40,000 small businesses directly affected by the overcharges. The remediation efforts underscore the bank's attempt to rectify the financial impact on its client base, although ASIC's legal action suggests the regulator deems these efforts insufficient to negate the need for formal proceedings against the bank for its alleged CBA misleading conduct ASIC.
Legal Implications and ASIC's Objectives
The ongoing legal action by ASIC against the Commonwealth Bank regarding ASIC sues Commonwealth Bank CommBiz fees seeks various outcomes from the court. The regulator is pursuing declarations that CBA engaged in the alleged misconduct, alongside significant pecuniary penalties. Additionally, ASIC is requesting adverse publicity orders, which would compel the bank to publicly acknowledge its wrongdoing, as well as ancillary orders and the recovery of legal costs incurred by the regulator.
The fact that a case management hearing has not yet been scheduled indicates the early stages of these proceedings. This case serves as a critical reminder for financial institutions about the paramount importance of transparent fee disclosure and robust internal governance. The allegations of long-term overcharging and delayed corrective action, despite internal audits and customer complaints, underscore the regulatory expectation that banks must proactively identify and rectify systemic issues to ensure fair and honest dealings with their customers.
Practical Implications
Compliance officers and legal counsel in financial institutions should review their fee disclosure practices, particularly for business banking platforms, to ensure transparency and avoid regulatory action. This case highlights ASIC's focus on long-standing governance failures and the importance of robust internal controls to identify and correct potential overcharges, even those stemming from historical system configurations.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Australia
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
