South Africa Labour Court: 184 Overdue Judgments Reported
Legal News

South Africa Labour Court: 184 Overdue Judgments Reported

South Africa·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 6 min read

Summary

  • South Africa has 443 court judgments overdue by more than six months, out of 2,124 reserved matters.
  • The Labour Courts account for 184 (42%) of these overdue judgments, showing a steep increase in recent years.
  • Acting judges are responsible for 62% of national overdue judgments and 93% of those in the Labour Courts.
  • The Labour Court operates with only 13 permanent judge posts, a number unchanged for 15 years.
  • Recruitment for permanent Labour Court judges is challenging, with vacancies frequently re-advertised due to a lack of suitable applicants.

Escalating Delays in South Africa's Labour Courts

The Labour Court, which serves the entire nation, operates with only 13 judges' posts, a number that has remained unchanged for 15 years.

South Africa's judicial system is grappling with a significant backlog of reserved judgments, with 443 cases nationally outstanding for over six months, according to the latest Reserved Judgments Report from the Office of the Chief Justice. This figure is drawn from a total of 2,124 matters where judgment has been reserved across various courts. While the Judicial Norms and Standards advocate for judgment delivery within three months, the report, like GroundUp, applies a more lenient six-month benchmark for identifying overdue cases.

Alarmingly, the four Labour Court divisions—located in Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, and Gqeberha—are disproportionately affected, accounting for 184 of these 443 late judgments, which represents 42% of the national total. This issue has seen a steep increase in recent years. For instance, Johannesburg's Labour Court recorded 37 late judgments in 2019, a number that has since surged to 113. Similarly, Cape Town's figure rose from a peak of six in 2019 to 37 currently, and Durban's from four to 32. Gqeberha stands as an exception, with its late judgments decreasing from a 2023 peak of 18 to just two.

The acceleration of these delays within the Labour Courts has been particularly pronounced over the past year. The number of late judgments across the four divisions climbed from 85 in October 2025 to 129 by January 2026, then to 163 in April, and reaching 184 by July. While the national count of 443 overdue judgments is marginally lower than the 445 reported in the preceding term, the Labour Court's specific backlog increased from 163 to 184 during the same period. Beyond the Labour Courts, the Gauteng division of the High Court in Pretoria recorded the second-highest number of late judgments nationally, with 60, followed by the Labour Court in Cape Town. Notably, the Labour Appeal Court, Electoral Court, and Competition Appeal Court reported no late judgments.

The Pervasive Influence of Acting Judges

A significant factor contributing to the South Africa judicial backlog in judgments is the reliance on acting judges. Of the 443 judgments outstanding for more than six months across the country, 276, or 62%, were reserved by acting judges. This proportion becomes even more pronounced within the Labour Courts, where acting judges are responsible for 93% of the overdue judgments, totaling 172 out of 184 cases.

Specific examples highlight this trend: in Johannesburg, 108 of the 113 late judgments were attributed to acting judges; in Durban, all 32 overdue judgments were by acting judges; in Cape Town, 31 of 37; and in Gqeberha, one of the two. Mbekezeli Benjamin of Judges Matter points out that Labour Courts frequently depend on acting judges due to permanent judges taking extended leave and numerous posts remaining vacant. Since 2022, seven of the Labour Court's most senior judges have either retired, been promoted, or transferred, yet only five of these vacancies have been filled.

Systemic Challenges and Recruitment Difficulties

The persistent issue of South Africa labour court overdue judgments is rooted in a combination of factors, including a shortage of permanent judges and an expanding workload. The Labour Court, which serves the entire nation, operates with only 13 judges' posts, a number that has remained unchanged for 15 years. This static capacity struggles to meet the demands of an increasing caseload.

The volume of cases has risen partly due to a weak economy, leading to more frequent retrenchments and dismissals. Furthermore, the growth in employment through short-term contracts has resulted in a greater number of disputes being brought directly before the Labour Courts, rather than being resolved through the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA). The Judicial Service Commission (JSC) has faced challenges in filling vacancies, having to re-advertise Labour Court posts at least three times since 2021 because too few suitable candidates applied. For instance, despite three posts being advertised in April and October 2025, only one appointment was made in each round. While acting judges do increase the court's capacity, they are not always as efficient in finalising matters as permanent judges. Their appointments can be as brief as a week, and they often encounter difficulties completing judgments after returning to their private legal practices.

Why Overdue Judgments Matter

The significant delays in judgment delivery, particularly the high number of South Africa labour court overdue judgments, have profound implications for the rule of law and access to justice. Prolonged waiting periods undermine public confidence in the judicial system and can cause substantial financial and emotional distress for litigants awaiting resolution. The reliance on acting judges, while necessary to address capacity gaps, introduces its own set of challenges, including potential inefficiencies and difficulties in ensuring timely finalisation of cases once these judges return to their primary legal careers.

This situation, highlighted by the ZA reserved judgments report, underscores a critical South Africa judicial backlog that demands urgent attention. The consistent increase in labour court judgment delays, despite a slight national decrease in overdue judgments, indicates a specific and worsening problem within this crucial sector. Addressing the shortage of permanent judges, streamlining recruitment processes, and ensuring adequate support for acting judges are essential steps to mitigate these delays and uphold the effectiveness of the justice system.

Practical Implications

Lawyers and compliance officers handling labour disputes in South Africa must factor in significantly extended timelines for judgment delivery, particularly given the high number of overdue judgments and the reliance on acting judges. This necessitates adjusting client expectations, litigation strategies, and financial provisions for prolonged legal processes.

Source

Source: Original reporting via GroundUp and the Office of the Chief Justice

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.