Florida Appeals Court: Robert Perdue v. Sam Domicilium Appeal

On October 23, 2026, the District Court of Appeal of Florida, Second District, received an appeal filed by Robert Perdue, designated as the Appellant, against Sam Domicilium Charleston Borrower LLC, formerly known as Sam Domicilium Charleston Equity LLC, the Appellee, originating from the Circuit Court for Pinellas County. Robert Perdue initiated this appellate action to challenge a decision rendered by the Circuit Court for Pinellas County. The opposing party in this appeal is Sam Domicilium Charleston Borrower LLC, which has undergone a name change from its previous designation as Sam Domicilium Charleston Equity LLC. The provided excerpt does not offer any details regarding the nature of the underlying dispute, the specific ruling being appealed, or the ultimate outcome of this appellate proceeding.

This case represents a standard appellate review process within Florida's judicial system, where a party dissatisfied with a circuit court's final judgment seeks a higher court's re-examination of alleged legal errors. For legal professionals, this underscores the critical importance of meticulously preserving issues for appeal at the trial court level and thoroughly understanding the various standards of review applied by appellate courts. These standards can differ significantly depending on whether the issue under review is a question of law, a finding of fact, or a discretionary ruling by the trial court. The corporate name change of the appellee also serves as a practical reminder for practitioners to ensure accurate party identification and to conduct due diligence regarding corporate structures in litigation.

In Florida, the District Courts of Appeal exercise mandatory appellate jurisdiction over final judgments issued by circuit courts, as explicitly established by Article V, Section 4(b)(1) of the Florida Constitution and further detailed in Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.030(b)(1)(A). The Circuit Court for Pinellas County functions as a trial court of general jurisdiction, and its final orders are subject to review by the appropriate District Court of Appeal. Appeals typically involve a comprehensive review of the trial court record to ascertain whether any reversible error occurred, with the appellate court generally deferring to the trial court's factual findings unless they are clearly erroneous, while reviewing legal conclusions de novo.

The primary parties involved in this appellate matter are Robert Perdue, who is the Appellant seeking to overturn a lower court decision, and Sam Domicilium Charleston Borrower LLC, formerly known as Sam Domicilium Charleston Equity LLC, who is the Appellee defending the lower court's ruling. The initial judicial action that led to this appeal originated from the Circuit Court for Pinellas County. The reviewing body for this appeal is the District Court of Appeal of Florida, Second District, which is one of the state's intermediate appellate courts responsible for hearing appeals from trial courts within its geographical jurisdiction.

Attorneys should pay close attention to the procedural requirements for filing and responding to appeals in Florida, including strict adherence to deadlines, proper preparation of the appellate record, and the crafting of persuasive briefs. A comprehensive understanding of the specific issues that can be raised on appeal and the applicable standards of review is absolutely crucial for effective appellate advocacy. Given that the outcome of this appeal is not reported in the provided excerpt, its potential impact on precedent or the specific parties involved remains unknown, necessitating continued monitoring for any future developments or published opinions.