Fifth Circuit: Mississippi Social Media Law Injunction Reversed
Case Law

Fifth Circuit: Mississippi Social Media Law Injunction Reversed

United States·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 5 min read

Summary

  • The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals lifted a preliminary injunction against Mississippi's Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act.
  • This decision means the law's age verification and parental consent requirements are no longer blocked for nine major social media platforms.
  • The court found the lower court erred by issuing a broad injunction without sufficient specific evidence of unconstitutionality as applied to individual platforms.
  • The law, enacted in 2024 after a teen's suicide, mandates age verification, parental consent for minors' accounts, and harm mitigation strategies.
  • The case has been remanded for further proceedings, and the question of the law's First Amendment constitutionality remains open.

What Happened

Crucially, the fundamental question of whether the Mississippi social media law ultimately violates the First Amendment remains unresolved and will be a central focus as the litigation continues.

The U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals recently reversed a lower court's preliminary injunction that had blocked Mississippi's Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act. This decision means the age-verification and parental-consent requirements of the law are no longer enjoined for nine major social media platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, Reddit, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor, and Dreamwidth. The unanimous three-judge panel determined that the district court had insufficient evidence to justify a complete halt to the law's enforcement against these specific companies.

Writing for the panel, U.S. Circuit Judge Cory T. Wilson explained that the internet advocacy group NetChoice failed to provide a sufficiently detailed record demonstrating the statute's unconstitutionality as applied to the unique features and sites of its member platforms. The appellate court concluded that the lower court erred by issuing a broad injunction without conducting the intensive, fact-specific analysis required for such "as-applied" relief.

Judge Wilson emphasized that the district court's decision was premature, if not unwarranted, because it lacked the particularized evidence necessary to craft a narrowly tailored injunction. General assertions that the law's requirements would be burdensome were deemed inadequate to support a complete bar on enforcement for the nine covered platforms. This ruling marks a significant development in the ongoing legal challenge to the Mississippi social media law.

The Mississippi Social Media Law

The Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, enacted in Mississippi in 2024, mandates several requirements for covered interactive platforms. The legislation was prompted by the tragic suicide of 16-year-old Walker Montgomery, who became a victim of an online sextortion scheme. Its core provisions aim to enhance online safety for minors.

Under the act, social media platforms must make commercially reasonable efforts to verify the ages of their users. Furthermore, they are required to obtain parental consent before allowing accounts to be held by individuals known to be minors. The law also compels platforms to implement strategies designed to mitigate various harms to minors that are explicitly listed within the statute.

Beyond age verification and parental consent, the act places limitations on the collection and use of data pertaining to minors. It also establishes mechanisms for enforcement, authorizing both parents and the state's attorney general to take action against non-compliant platforms. Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch praised the Fifth Circuit's decision, stating that the law asks social media companies to make reasonable changes that a responsible corporate citizen should embrace, and calling it an important victory in the fight to keep children safe in the digital age.

Legal Context and Procedural History

This recent Fifth Circuit ruling is part of a complex legal battle initiated by NetChoice, a trade association representing prominent internet companies. Initially, NetChoice successfully secured a facial preliminary injunction against the Mississippi social media law from a federal judge in Mississippi in 2024, which broadly blocked its enforcement. However, following the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Moody v. NetChoice, the Fifth Circuit vacated that initial order and remanded the case for reconsideration.

Upon remand, NetChoice altered its legal strategy, shifting from a facial challenge—which argues a law is unconstitutional in all circumstances—to an as-applied challenge, contending the law is unconstitutional as it applies to specific platforms and their features. Despite this shift, the lower court once again blocked the law as it pertained to the nine platforms represented by NetChoice. The Fifth Circuit subsequently stayed this second injunction pending appeal, a decision that the Supreme Court ultimately upheld by leaving the stay in place.

The case has now been remanded to the lower court for further proceedings, which must align with the Supreme Court's guidance in Moody v. NetChoice and the Fifth Circuit's own prior instructions. Crucially, the fundamental question of whether the Mississippi social media law ultimately violates the First Amendment remains unresolved and will be a central focus as the litigation continues.

Industry Response and Future Outlook

The decision from the Fifth Circuit has elicited varied reactions from the involved parties. While Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch lauded the ruling as a significant step towards protecting children online, NetChoice expressed its disappointment. Paul Taske, co-director of the NetChoice Litigation Center, affirmed that the ruling does not declare the act constitutional.

Taske highlighted that Justice Kavanaugh has previously indicated that NetChoice is likely to succeed on the merits of its case. NetChoice is currently evaluating all available options to ensure the preservation of lawful speech access within Mississippi. The current ruling primarily addresses the procedural sufficiency of the injunction, rather than the underlying constitutionality of the law itself.

The ongoing legal challenge underscores the tension between state efforts to safeguard minors online and concerns about potential infringements on First Amendment rights. As the case returns to the district court, platforms operating in Mississippi will need to consider the implications of the lifted injunction while the broader constitutional questions surrounding the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act continue to be litigated.

Practical Implications

Lawyers advising social media platforms operating in Mississippi should note that the Fifth Circuit has lifted the preliminary injunction against the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, meaning the law's age verification and parental consent requirements are no longer blocked for the nine platforms involved in the lawsuit. Compliance officers should assess their readiness to implement these provisions in Mississippi, as the law is now potentially enforceable while the constitutional challenge continues.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Courthouse News Service.

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.