
Federal Court: Pseudonym Orders Issued In eSafety Telegram Case
Summary
- The Australian Federal Court has granted extensive pseudonymity and non-publication orders in a case brought by the eSafety Commissioner against Telegram entities.
- These orders aim to protect individuals and ensure the proper administration of justice, citing sections of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976.
- The underlying proceedings allege Telegram breached the Online Safety Act by facilitating access to "pro-terror material" and "extreme crime and violence material."
- Specific pseudonyms, including "Company Y," "Mr X," "Person A," and "Person B," were assigned, with a 10-year publication ban on their identifying information.
- This action is part of the eSafety Commissioner's ongoing enforcement, following a recent $750,000 penalty against X Corp for similar online safety breaches.
Court Grants Extensive Protection Orders
The court determined that the orders would help protect the safety of individuals, as permitted by section 37AG(1)(c), and prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, in line with section 37AG(1)(a) of the Act.
The Australian Federal Court has issued comprehensive pseudonymity and non-publication orders in proceedings initiated by the eSafety Commissioner against Telegram FZ-LLC and Telegram Messenger Inc. These orders are designed to safeguard specific individuals and to prevent any prejudice to the proper administration of justice, as detailed in the case eSafety Commissioner v Telegram FZ-LLC (suppression orders) [2026] FCA 1700.
Under the court's direction, an employer company will be referred to as "company Y," its Chief Executive Officer as "Mr X," and two proposed witnesses as "Person A" and "Person B." The court also imposed a significant 10-year prohibition on the publication of the names and identifying details of Company Y, Mr X, Person A, and Person B. This ban extends to any information that could identify these individuals or Company Y, as well as the confidential information contained within the affidavits and the specific subject matter of that confidential information. The issue of costs for the proceedings was reserved by the court.
Allegations of Online Safety Breaches
The underlying legal action sees the eSafety Commissioner seeking declarations and pecuniary penalties, alleging breaches of the Online Safety (Relevant Electronic Services – Class 1A and Class 1B Material) Industry Standard 2024 (Cth), referred to as the RES Standard. This standard was promulgated under section 145(1) of the Online Safety Act 2021 (Cth). The Commissioner claims that the Telegram entities contravened section 146(1) of the Online Safety Act.
The alleged conduct involved facilitating access to or the distribution of what is classified as Class 1A material. According to section 6(1) of the RES Standard, Class 1A material encompasses "pro-terror material" or "extreme crime and violence material." In her statement of claim, the Commissioner asserted that end-users in Australia were involved, and that the relevant Telegram entity failed to detect and remove pro-terror material from its platform, including videos depicting terrorist executions and mass shootings.
Legal Basis for Protective Measures
The Federal Court's decision to grant these protective orders was grounded in specific provisions of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court determined that the orders would help protect the safety of individuals, as permitted by section 37AG(1)(c), and prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, in line with section 37AG(1)(a) of the Act. The Commissioner had specifically requested these pseudonym orders, citing concerns for witness safety and the necessity of preventing any adverse impact on the proper administration of justice in connection with the commissioner's ongoing work.
In reaching its decision, the court considered affidavit evidence, including submissions from Ms Snell, the eSafety Commissioner's General Counsel, Mr X (the CEO of Company Y), Person A, and Person B. Additionally, the court issued non-publication orders covering specific portions of Ms Snell’s affidavit and the entirety of Mr X’s affidavit, underscoring the sensitivity of the information presented.
Broader Context of eSafety Enforcement
This case against Telegram forms part of the eSafety Commissioner's broader efforts to enforce online safety regulations. In late July, the Commissioner publicly announced the commencement of civil penalty proceedings before the Federal Court against Telegram's provider, specifically citing its alleged failure to detect and remove pro-terror material from its platform.
This action follows a significant ruling on 21 May 2026, where the Federal Court of Australia mandated X Corp, the operator of the social media service formerly known as Twitter, to pay $650,000 as a pecuniary penalty to the Commonwealth of Australia. X Corp was also ordered to contribute an additional $100,000 towards the eSafety Commissioner’s costs, highlighting the court's willingness to impose substantial penalties for non-compliance with online safety directives.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising online platforms and tech companies in Australia should note the Federal Court's willingness to grant extensive pseudonym and non-publication orders to protect individuals and the administration of justice in cases brought by the eSafety Commissioner. This indicates a strong judicial stance on safeguarding sensitive information and witnesses in online safety enforcement actions, potentially influencing litigation strategies and compliance requirements under the Online Safety Act.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Australia
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
