Sizwe Snail: InfoReg Not South Africa's AI Regulator
Legal News

Sizwe Snail: InfoReg Not South Africa's AI Regulator

South Africa·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • Sizwe Snail ka Mtuze argues the Information Regulator (InfoReg) should not also serve as South Africa's AI regulator.
  • He advocates for an independent AI institute to coordinate with InfoReg on data-related matters.
  • The urgency for such an institute is high due to rapid AI development, despite the withdrawal of South Africa's draft National AI Policy.
  • Snail ka Mtuze, an initial InfoReg member, reflected on the five-year implementation of the Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA).
  • InfoReg has issued enforcement notices, including against First National Bank, a TVET college, and even government departments, underscoring broad compliance requirements.

The Debate Over AI Regulation

The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence necessitates the immediate establishment of a dedicated, independent AI institute in South Africa, according to a prominent cyber law expert.

A prominent voice in South African cyber law has cautioned against assigning the Information Regulator (InfoReg) the dual responsibility of overseeing artificial intelligence. Sizwe Snail ka Mtuze, an Adjunct Professor of cyber law at Nelson Mandela University and Senior Partner at Snail Attorneys, articulated this perspective during his reflection on five years since the Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA) came into effect. Snail ka Mtuze, who was among the initial members instrumental in establishing the InfoReg office in December 2016, shared his insights at the recent 2026 Governance Risk and Compliance Summit, hosted by ITWeb.

Instead of an expanded InfoReg AI mandate, Snail ka Mtuze advocates for the creation of an independent AI institute in South Africa. This new body would be tasked with coordinating with the InfoReg on issues pertaining to data infringements and related concerns. He stressed that the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence necessitates the immediate establishment of a dedicated, independent AI institute in South Africa, according to a prominent cyber law expert, particularly given the earlier withdrawal of the country's draft National AI Policy.

Snail ka Mtuze proposed that the president should initiate the formation of this institute through a proclamation, granting it the necessary powers to begin its work. This proactive approach would ensure that an organization is already in place to address AI-related matters by the time a comprehensive AI policy is finalized. He emphasized that establishing such an institute now would be beneficial, urging the government to proceed with its creation and subsequently develop supporting legislation.

InfoReg's Established Role and POPIA's Impact

The Information Regulator, currently led by Advocate Pansy Tlakula as its Chairperson, holds the critical mandate of monitoring and enforcing compliance with both POPIA and the Promotion of Access to Information Act across public and private entities. POPIA itself became fully effective on July 1, 2021, following a one-year grace period provided for organizations to align their practices with the new legislation.

In his POPIA five year reflection, Snail ka Mtuze characterized the law as robust but acknowledged its potential for improvement. He pointed out that the 2013 legislation lags somewhat behind the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which was enacted in 2018, noting that Europe possesses five years of experience that South Africa does not yet have with POPIA. He also highlighted specific areas for enhancement, including ambiguities surrounding the personal information of juristic persons and overlaps between POPIA, direct-marketing guidelines, and the National Consumer Commission.

Enforcement Actions and Compliance Imperatives

The InfoReg has demonstrated its commitment to its mandate through various milestones, including the issuance of enforcement notices. Recent examples of entities found in breach of POPIA include First National Bank and a TVET college, underscoring the regulator's active role in ensuring adherence to data privacy standards. Snail ka Mtuze observed that private sector organizations have generally engaged proactively with the regulator, implementing system updates and staff training to meet compliance requirements.

Crucially, Snail ka Mtuze stressed that compliance with POPIA must permeate all levels of an organization, extending beyond executives to include every employee, even cleaning staff. He commended the InfoReg for its effectiveness in compelling organizations to provide information and for taking decisive action against various entities, including the State Security Agency. The regulator has even cracked down on its own funding body, the Department of Justice and Correctional Services, which had faced hacking incidents as early as 2020. Despite initial remedial meetings, enforcement notices were ultimately issued, signaling the InfoReg's unwavering stance that all entities, regardless of their nature, must comply with the law.

Practical Implications

Lawyers and compliance officers in South Africa should closely monitor the debate and potential establishment of an independent AI regulatory body, as this will define future compliance frameworks for AI technologies. They should also note the InfoReg's ongoing enforcement of POPIA, which highlights the need for robust data privacy compliance across all levels of an organization, including with new technologies.

Source

Source: Original reporting via ITWeb

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.