
Ekurhuleni Tembisa Residents: City Ignores Services Court Order
Summary
- In 2019, residents of Monflorah Park, Tembisa, secured a Gauteng High Court order preventing their eviction by the City of Ekurhuleni.
- Despite this court victory, residents report living in inhumane conditions without basic services like water, electricity, and sanitation, years after the ruling.
- The City of Ekurhuleni claims to provide some services, but residents state these are inadequate or misdirected, and there are no current housing development plans for the settlement.
- The community, which has grown to over 200 households, plans to seek intervention from the SA Human Rights Commission due to the persistent lack of essential services.
The Unfulfilled Promise of a Court Victory
The persistent lack of essential services, despite a favorable Gauteng High Court eviction interdict, underscores the significant challenges communities face in enforcing judicial orders against municipalities for basic provisions.
Residents in Monflorah Park, Tembisa, continue to endure dire living conditions, lacking fundamental services such as running water, electricity, and adequate sanitation, despite a significant legal triumph against the City of Ekurhuleni five years ago. In 2019, the community secured a Gauteng High Court order that halted the City's attempts to evict them from the land they had occupied since August 2018. This land, which had been vacant for over a decade and was a known site for criminal activity, became home to many unemployed individuals unable to afford rent, including pensioner Meisie Tshabalala, who joined after repeatedly failing to secure an RDP housing application.
The 2019 court ruling, issued by Judge Anthony Millar, specifically prohibited the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department (EMPD) and the City from carrying out further evictions without a proper court order. Furthermore, the judgment mandated the City to compensate each occupier R1,500 for property damages incurred during previous demolition attempts, which had seen shacks destroyed more than ten times. The court also issued an interdict against any form of harassment, intimidation, or threats directed at the occupiers. While the City ceased its eviction efforts following this decisive Ekurhuleni Tembisa residents services court order, residents contend that the municipality subsequently ignored their pleas for the provision of essential services, leading to a protracted struggle for basic human dignity.
Daily Struggles and Municipal Responses
The absence of basic services has created severe daily challenges for the more than 200 households now residing in Monflorah Park. Meisie Tshabalala, for instance, must walk over 500 meters to access a communal tap, returning with heavy water containers, highlighting the physical toll of the service vacuum. Paulina Lynette Mbungele, living with her four children in a single room, faces the critical issue of storing chronic medication without refrigeration, as electricity is unavailable, and she cannot afford an illegal connection. Another resident, Alfred Mashava, who moved to the settlement due to unemployment and a subsequent injury that left him unable to work, attempted to use illegal connections for water and electricity, only to find the water supply non-existent and the power unreliable.
Community representative Florah Tjabadi reports that while City officials initially indicated they would consider formalizing the settlement, years have passed with no tangible progress. Residents observe that nearby informal settlements, such as Duduza and Extension 8, have since received water, toilets, and electricity, intensifying their feeling of neglect regarding City of Ekurhuleni service delivery. In response to these allegations, Ekurhuleni spokesperson Zweli Dlamini denied that the City fails to provide basic services, asserting that water tankers are dispatched, chemical toilets are supplied, and waste removal services are active. However, Tjabadi disputes this, stating that water trucks deliver closer to Duduza and Extension 8, bypassing Monflorah Park, and that residents are forced to dig holes in their yards for human waste disposal. Dlamini also cited Eskom's assessment that the settlement's proximity to a river complicates the feasibility of electrification, adding that there are currently no housing development plans for the area.
Seeking Further Recourse
The persistent lack of essential services, despite a favorable Gauteng High Court eviction interdict, underscores the significant challenges communities face in enforcing judicial orders against municipalities for basic provisions. Faced with what they describe as inhumane living conditions and the City's alleged inaction, the residents of Monflorah Park Tembisa basic services are now preparing to escalate their plight. They intend to approach the SA Human Rights Commission for intervention, seeking to leverage its mandate to protect and promote human rights in South Africa.
This planned engagement with the SA Human Rights Commission highlights the ongoing struggle for the right to basic services in South Africa, even after legal victories. The community's determination reflects a broader pattern where court judgments, while legally binding, do not always translate into immediate or comprehensive improvements in service delivery on the ground. As Alfred Mashava articulated, "The government should own up to its promise and provide our community with services," a sentiment that resonates deeply within the community as they pursue additional avenues to secure the fundamental amenities they believe are their right.
Practical Implications
This case highlights the persistent challenges in enforcing court orders against municipalities for the provision of basic services, even after a favorable judgment. Lawyers advising communities or litigating against local governments should be prepared for potential non-compliance post-judgment and consider strategies for enforcement, including further litigation or engaging bodies like the SA Human Rights Commission.
Source
Source: Original reporting via GroundUp
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
