South Africa Labour Court: Judgment Delays Worsen, 184 Cases Over 6 Months
Legal News

South Africa Labour Court: Judgment Delays Worsen, 184 Cases Over 6 Months

South Africa·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 5 min read

Summary

  • South Africa's Labour Courts account for 42% of the country's judgments outstanding for over six months, totaling 184 cases.
  • Late judgments in Labour Courts have significantly increased in Johannesburg, Cape Town, and Durban since 2019, with an accelerated rise in the past year.
  • Judicial Norms and Standards aim for judgment delivery within three months, but many Labour Court rulings exceed even the more lenient six-month benchmark.
  • A shortage of permanent judges, static judicial posts for 15 years, and a growing workload contribute to the delays.
  • Acting judges are responsible for 93% of the Labour Courts' late judgments, largely due to permanent judge vacancies and difficulties in filling positions.

The Escalating Challenge in Labour Courts

The significant reliance on acting judges, who are responsible for a staggering 93% of late judgments in the Labour Courts, highlights a critical systemic issue.

South Africa's judicial system is grappling with a significant backlog of reserved judgments, with 2,124 matters awaiting decisions across various courts. Of these, a substantial 443 have been outstanding for more than six months, according to the latest Reserved Judgments Report from the Office of the Chief Justice. The Labour Court divisions, specifically in Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, and Gqeberha, are disproportionately contributing to this national issue, accounting for 184 of these 443 delayed rulings, which represents 42% of the total.

The number of late judgments within the Labour Courts has seen a sharp increase over recent years. In Johannesburg, the figure has surged from a peak of 37 in 2019 to 113 currently. Cape Town's Labour Court experienced a similar trend, rising from six in 2019 to 37, while Durban's late judgments climbed from four to 32. Gqeberha stands as an exception, with its late judgments decreasing from a 2023 peak of 18 to just two. This upward trend has also accelerated in the past year, with late judgments across the four divisions rising from 85 in October 2025 to 129 in January 2026, then to 163 in April, and finally reaching 184 by July.

Judicial Standards and Persistent Delays

The Judicial Norms and Standards stipulate that judgments should ideally be delivered within three months of a case being heard. However, the Office of the Chief Justice and GroundUp employ a more lenient benchmark, classifying judgments as 'late' if they remain outstanding for over six months. The national total of 443 late judgments reflects those that have exceeded this extended six-month period.

While the national count of late judgments saw a slight decrease of two from the previous term's 445, the Labour Court's backlog actually worsened. Over the same period, the number of delayed rulings in the Labour Courts increased from 163 to 184. Beyond the Labour Courts, the Gauteng division of the High Court in Pretoria recorded the second-highest number of late judgments nationally with 60, followed by the Labour Court in Cape Town. Notably, the Labour Appeal Court, Electoral Court, and Competition Appeal Court reported no late judgments.

Systemic Pressures and the Acting Judge Factor

Mbekezeli Benjamin of Judges Matter attributes the growing number of South Africa Labour Court judgment delays primarily to a shortage of permanent judges and an expanding workload. The Labour Court, which serves the entire country, has only 13 judges' posts, a number that has remained unchanged for 15 years. This static capacity struggles to cope with an increased volume of cases, partly driven by a weak economy, a rise in retrenchments, and more dismissals. Furthermore, the proliferation of short-term employment contracts has led to a greater number of disputes being referred directly to the Labour Courts, bypassing the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA).

A significant contributor to the backlog is the heavy reliance on acting judges. Nationally, acting judges are responsible for 276 of the 443 late judgments, representing 62% of the total. This proportion is even higher within the Labour Courts, where acting judges account for 172 of the 184 late judgments, a staggering 93%. Specifically, 108 of Johannesburg's 113 late judgments, all 32 in Durban, 31 of 37 in Cape Town, and one of two in Gqeberha were reserved by acting judges. This reliance stems from permanent judges taking extended leave and numerous vacant posts. Since 2022, seven senior judges have retired, been promoted, or transferred, yet only five of these vacancies have been filled. The Judicial Service Commission has had to re-advertise Labour Court vacancies at least three times since 2021 due to an insufficient number of suitable applicants, with only one appointment made in each of the two rounds of advertisements in April and October 2025.

Prolonged Uncertainty in Labour Disputes

The persistent South Africa Labour Court judgment delays create significant challenges for all parties involved in labour disputes. The extended waiting periods for rulings mean that employers and employees face prolonged uncertainty regarding their legal positions, impacting business operations, individual livelihoods, and the overall resolution of workplace conflicts. This situation necessitates a strategic approach for legal practitioners and compliance officers, who must now factor in these extended timelines when advising clients.

Managing client expectations regarding the duration of litigation, particularly in the Labour Courts, becomes paramount. The current environment may also encourage a more aggressive exploration of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms to circumvent the lengthy judicial process. Ultimately, the increasing backlog and the disproportionate contribution of acting judges to these delays underscore a systemic issue that prolongs uncertainty and complicates the landscape of labour law in South Africa.

Practical Implications

Lawyers and compliance officers should anticipate significant delays in obtaining judgments from South African Labour Courts, particularly in Johannesburg, Cape Town, and Durban, and especially when cases are heard by acting judges. This necessitates managing client expectations regarding litigation timelines, potentially exploring alternative dispute resolution more aggressively, and factoring in prolonged uncertainty when advising on labour disputes or retrenchments.

Source

Source: Original reporting via GroundUp and the Office of the Chief Justice

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.