
Ontario Court: Dufferin-Peel School Board Not Vicariously Liable for Teacher Abuse
Summary
- The Ontario Superior Court dismissed a claim for damages against the Dufferin-Peel Catholic District School Board for a teacher's sexual assault.
- The court found the school board was not vicariously liable, despite the teacher's employment, because the assault was not sufficiently connected to his assigned teaching duties.
- The ruling applied the Bazley v. Curry test, satisfying the first prong (close relationship) but failing the second (materialization of enterprise risk).
- No punitive damages or past income loss were awarded, though the court acknowledged the plaintiff's significant psychological impairment from the assault.
- The decision highlights the stringent requirements for establishing school board vicarious liability in teacher abuse cases.
Court Dismisses Vicarious Liability Claim Against School Board
Justice Pamela L. Hebner concluded that there was no adequate link between the sexual assault and R.G.W.'s assigned English-teaching tasks to establish this connection.
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has dismissed a claim for damages against the Dufferin-Peel Catholic District School Board, ruling that the board was not vicariously liable for a teacher's sexual assault of a student. The case, identified as C.P.G. v. Dufferin-Peel Catholic District School Board, 2026 ONSC 6046, involved a plaintiff who attended an elementary school under the board's predecessor from September 1957 to June 1966, and a secondary school from September 1966 to February 1972.
The perpetrator, R.G.W., began employment with a predecessor school board in January 1964. He taught sixth grade at the plaintiff's elementary school between January and June 1964. Later, from September 1966 to February 1967, R.G.W. taught eighth grade at another school within the same board, becoming its acting principal in November 1966 before resigning in February 1967. In 2003, R.G.W. was convicted of indecent assault, committed between September 4, 1964, and June 30, 1965, when the plaintiff was 13 years old, under section 148 of the Criminal Code.
The plaintiff sought general damages ranging from $200,000 to $275,000, along with compensation for past income loss, arguing that the assault prevented him from completing grade 13, attending university, and pursuing a more financially and personally rewarding career than his eventual 28-year tenure as a firefighter. The court accepted the plaintiff's evidence regarding R.G.W.'s actions and the resulting mild to moderate psychological impairment, acknowledging the profound impacts of the single incident of sexual violence that occurred after months of grooming.
Application of Bazley v. Curry Test
In assessing the Dufferin-Peel school board's potential vicarious liability for the teacher abuse, the Superior Court applied the two-pronged test established in Bazley v. Curry, 1999 CanLII 692 (SCC). The court determined that the first prong of the test was satisfied, recognizing a sufficiently close relationship between R.G.W., who was the plaintiff's English teacher, and the school board. This established the initial connection required for potential liability.
However, the court found that the second prong of the Bazley test was not met. This prong requires a sufficient connection between the employee's assigned duties and the wrongful act, such that the act can be considered a materialization of the enterprise risks created by the employment. Justice Pamela L. Hebner concluded that there was no adequate link between the sexual assault and R.G.W.'s assigned English-teaching tasks to establish this connection. The court noted that the only connection was a 'but for' link, meaning the assault would not have occurred had R.G.W. not been employed by the school board, but this alone was insufficient to establish vicarious liability.
Implications for School Board Liability
This ruling clarifies the high bar for establishing school board vicarious liability in cases of teacher sexual assault, particularly concerning the second prong of the Bazley v. Curry test. Despite acknowledging the severe psychological impairment suffered by the plaintiff due to the assault, the court declined to award punitive damages against the Dufferin-Peel Catholic District School Board, finding no evidence of egregious conduct on its part.
Furthermore, the Superior Court found no justification for the plaintiff's claim for past income loss. Justice Hebner observed that the plaintiff had a highly successful 28-year career in firefighting, and there was no evidence presented to suggest he would have pursued a different career path had the assault not occurred. The court's decision underscores that while the profound impact of such incidents is recognized, the legal framework for attributing vicarious liability to an employer for teacher misconduct requires a direct connection to the enterprise's inherent risks, beyond merely the fact of employment. The parties have been permitted to file written submissions regarding costs.
Practical Implications
This ruling clarifies the application of the second prong of the Bazley v. Curry test for vicarious liability in Canada, indicating that a school board may not be held vicariously liable for a teacher's sexual assault if there is no sufficient connection between the assault and the teacher's assigned duties. Lawyers advising school boards should review their policies and training to ensure they address enterprise risks, while lawyers representing victims should understand the high bar for establishing vicarious liability in such cases.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Canada
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
