
Chandra Sekar Barrister Fined £1,500 for Undermining Judge
Summary
- Barrister Chandra Sekar was fined £1,500 by a disciplinary tribunal for undermining HHJ Elizabeth Smaller during a criminal trial.
- Sekar questioned the judge's impartiality and informed the jury of a ruling made in their absence.
- He also persistently tried to re-argue a point the judge had already decided.
- The tribunal found Sekar breached his duty to the court, diminished public trust, and abused his advocate role, deeming his conduct professional misconduct.
- In addition to the fine, Sekar was ordered to pay the Bar Standards Board’s costs of £6,118.40.
Barrister's Conduct Under Scrutiny
This outcome serves as a critical reminder to all legal practitioners, particularly advocates, of the strict professional obligations regarding conduct towards the judiciary.
A disciplinary tribunal has imposed a £1,500 fine on barrister Chandra Sekar for repeatedly undermining HHJ Elizabeth Smaller during a criminal trial. Sekar's actions included questioning the judge's impartiality by asking if there was any point in making a submission, stating, "you're only going to rule against me anyway." This direct challenge to judicial authority formed a key part of the tribunal's findings regarding his professional conduct.
Further instances of misconduct involved Sekar informing the jury about a ruling the judge had made in their absence. He also persistently attempted to re-argue a point on which Judge Smaller had already delivered a decision. These actions were deemed to have gone beyond appropriate advocacy, leading to a formal finding of professional misconduct against the barrister.
Breaches of Professional Duty
The disciplinary tribunal concluded that Chandra Sekar had committed several serious breaches of his professional obligations. Specifically, he was found to have violated his fundamental duty to the court in the administration of justice. The tribunal also determined that his behavior was likely to diminish public trust and confidence in both himself and the legal profession as a whole.
Moreover, the tribunal found that Sekar had abused his role as an advocate. During cross-examination, Sekar himself conceded that his conduct could be perceived as undermining the judge and acknowledged that he had "gone over the line." While he maintained that his intention was not to undermine the court, he admitted to being rude to the judge and recognized that his actions were unwarranted.
Tribunal's Findings and Sanctions
The tribunal highlighted Sekar's attempt to re-argue a point that had already been ruled upon as particularly egregious, describing it as "unduly rude, inappropriate and, as had been accepted, persistent." This conduct, along with the other identified breaches, was ultimately classified as seriously reprehensible and amounting to professional misconduct. The tribunal's decision underscores the strict standards expected of barristers in their interactions with the judiciary.
For his professional misconduct, Chandra Sekar received a fine of £500 for each of the three charges, totaling £1,500. In addition to this financial penalty, the barrister was ordered to cover the Bar Standards Board’s costs, which amounted to £6,118.40. This outcome serves as a critical reminder to all legal practitioners, particularly advocates, of the strict professional obligations regarding conduct towards the judiciary.
Practical Implications
This case serves as a critical reminder to all legal practitioners, particularly advocates, of the strict professional obligations regarding conduct towards the judiciary. Lawyers must ensure their advocacy, while robust, never crosses into undermining judicial authority or disrespecting the court, as such actions can lead to significant disciplinary sanctions and reputational damage.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United Kingdom
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
