
CBA Bill C-34 Safe Social Media Act: Calls for Stronger Child Safety
Summary
- The Canadian Bar Association (CBA) supports Bill C-34's objectives but states it falls short of international online safety standards for children.
- The CBA advocates for a distinct legislative framework for children's online safety, aligning with the UNCRC and OPC's Children's Privacy Code.
- Concerns exist that Bill C-34 could lead to over-restriction of affirming content for 2SLGBTQIA+ youth and discriminatory algorithmic enforcement.
- The CBA recommends specialized child protection expertise within the regulatory commission and child-specific risk assessments.
- The bill's delegation of key standards to future regulations or the Commission is a significant concern for the CBA.
Critical Assessment of Canada's Online Safety Bill
Any effective strategy for children's online safety, according to the CBA, must be grounded in the principle of the child's best interests, as articulated in Article 3(1) of the UNCRC, and must facilitate meaningful child participation.
The Canadian Bar Association (CBA), representing 40,000 legal professionals nationwide, has formally communicated its concerns regarding Bill C-34, known as the Safe Social Media Act. In a submission to the Honourable Lisa Hepfner, M.P., Chair of the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage, the CBA acknowledged the bill's objectives but asserted that it falls short of current international benchmarks for online safety. This critique stems from the collective insights of the CBA's Child and Youth Law, Privacy and Access Law, Constitutional and Human Rights Law, and Sexual and Gender Diversity Alliance Sections.
The CBA's recommendations emphasize several critical areas, including the necessity of treating child safety as a distinct regulatory issue, upholding children's rights and ensuring their participation in legislative processes, and guaranteeing specialized expertise in children's rights within oversight bodies. Furthermore, the association highlighted the particular vulnerabilities of marginalized populations and raised broader constitutional, privacy, and regulatory considerations that require attention within the proposed legislation. The core message underscores the need for a more robust and child-centric approach to online safety.
Upholding Children's Rights in the Digital Sphere
A central tenet of the CBA's position is that children's online safety mandates a dedicated legislative framework that explicitly recognizes young people as rights holders. The association points to the United Kingdom's Data Protection Act and Children's Code as a global standard that Canada should emulate, aligning with its commitments under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of a Child (UNCRC) and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner's (OPC) recently introduced Children's Privacy Code. The CBA warns that integrating children's and adults' online safety provisions within a single regulatory scheme risks diminishing the unique rights of children.
Any effective strategy for children's online safety, according to the CBA, must be grounded in the principle of the child's best interests, as articulated in Article 3(1) of the UNCRC, and must facilitate meaningful child participation. The European Commission's Child Safety Online report and its proposed EU KIDS Act offer a model where primary responsibility rests with online service providers, incorporating graduated age-based and safety-by-design obligations that acknowledge children's developing capacities. The CBA also noted that the process for creating the OPC's Code demonstrates that genuine consultation with children is achievable, and they should similarly be heard on Bill C-34.
Addressing Vulnerabilities and Moderation Challenges
The CBA also raised specific concerns about how Bill C-34 might impact vulnerable groups, particularly 2SLGBTQIA+ youth. While the bill requires operators to restrict access for users under 16 to content not proven safe and to implement harm reduction measures, there is a risk that platforms could excessively limit affirming content related to 2SLGBTQIA+ identity, relationships, sexual health education, and gender-affirming care. Such content, if mislabeled as sexual or harmful, could be unduly restricted, despite its crucial supportive role for many young people and its connection to a child's right to information.
To mitigate this, the CBA suggests explicit statutory language clarifying that content is not inherently harmful or pornographic merely because it addresses sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, gender-affirming care, or 2SLGBTQIA+ relationships or sexual health. Furthermore, the bill's recognition of the unique risks posed by highly personalized AI chatbot interactions and the need for mandatory safeguards is welcomed. However, these safeguards must specifically target escalating suicidal or violent ideation without inadvertently flagging affirming discussions of sexual orientation or gender identity as indicators of self-harm. The CBA cautions that the "reasonable grounds to suspect" threshold, user flagging mechanisms, and safety-plan obligations could lead to discriminatory algorithmic over-enforcement, disproportionately affecting 2SLGBTQIA+ content, especially for Indigenous and racialized 2SLGBTQIA+ youth who often rely more on online support but face heightened risks. Operators, the CBA asserts, should evaluate actual risk rather than presuming certain content is inherently dangerous.
Oversight and Regulatory Framework Deficiencies
The CBA identified gaps in the proposed regulatory and oversight mechanisms within Bill C-34. Specifically, the risk assessments mandated under Sections 18(e) and 42(1) are not tailored to children's specific vulnerabilities. To address this, the association recommends that at least one member of the Commission overseeing the Act possess specialized expertise in child protection and children's rights, including the ability to conduct child-rights impact assessments (CRIAs).
As an alternative or supplementary measure, the CBA proposed the establishment of a National Commissioner for Children, which would enhance oversight and bring Canada into alignment with many other nations. A significant concern also arises from the bill's tendency to defer crucial standards to future regulations or the Commission itself, which the CBA views as problematic, potentially leading to uncertainty and insufficient protections. The CBA has indicated that more specific statutory language to address these concerns is available upon request.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising online platforms or child protection organizations should monitor the progression of Canada's Bill C-34, the Safe Social Media Act, given the Canadian Bar Association's critique that it falls short on children's online safety and rights. Compliance officers should anticipate potential amendments or regulatory interpretations that address the CBA's concerns, particularly regarding age-based obligations, content moderation for vulnerable groups like 2SLGBTQIA+ youth, and alignment with international child rights standards, to mitigate future legal and reputational risks.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Canada
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
