Atiku Demands INEC Result Verification Audit for Election Tech
Legal News

Atiku Demands INEC Result Verification Audit for Election Tech

Nigeria·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 6 min read

Summary

  • Atiku Abubakar requested an independent audit of INEC's proposed result-verification technology, including its source code and decision logs.
  • He also demanded INEC publish clear procedures for handling flagged result sheets and reaffirm the legal status of physical Form EC8A.
  • INEC's ICT director, Lawrence Bayode, explained that BVAS would photograph Form EC8A, enter figures electronically, and flag discrepancies before IReV upload, with the paper form remaining official.
  • Rival factions within the African Democratic Congress (ADC) made opposing demands to INEC, including enforcing a court judgment invalidating Atiku's nomination and postponing the mock exercise.
  • The All Progressives Grand Alliance (APGA) publicly endorsed President Bola Tinubu at a joint rally with the APC in Awka.

Call for Independent Election Technology Audit

The clarity on the legal status of physical Form EC8A versus electronic records and the process for resolving flagged discrepancies will be critical for future election petitions and challenges to results.

Former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar has formally requested the Independent National Election Commission (INEC) to permit external experts to scrutinize its proposed mechanisms for verifying polling-unit results. This demand for an independent audit of technology, which Mr. Abubakar described as incorporating artificial intelligence and intelligent document processing, precedes a nationwide mock accreditation exercise scheduled for November 28. The request, conveyed to the INEC chairman by Phrank Shaibu, Director of Strategic Communication for Mr. Atiku's campaign council, was made on behalf of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and its associated stakeholders. This comes despite a Federal High Court judgment on November 5 invalidating Mr. Atiku's presidential nomination under the ADC, a decision the party is currently appealing.

Mr. Abubakar specifically called for independent cybersecurity experts, representatives from political parties with technological expertise, and civil society technologists to meticulously examine the system's source code, its training data, and its decision logs. This comprehensive review is sought before the November 28 exercise takes place. Furthermore, he urged INEC to publicly outline its procedure for addressing flagged result sheets. This detailed procedure should clarify who is responsible for reviewing discrepancies, how decisions are formally recorded, the method for notifying political parties, and the process by which errors can be challenged.

A key aspect of Mr. Abubakar's demand centers on the legal standing of the physical Form EC8A. He has asked the commission to reaffirm its official status and to clearly explain the methodology for resolving any conflicts that may arise between paper records and the automated assessments generated by the new system. While Mr. Atiku's campaign council, through the Nigerian Tribune, reported these demands, INEC's official response to this specific audit request could not be independently verified in the available reporting.

INEC's Result Verification Process and Discrepancy Handling

INEC's ICT director, Lawrence Bayode, has previously offered insights into a portion of the commission's proposed result verification methodology. According to his explanation, presiding officers are expected to utilize the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) to capture photographic images of the completed Form EC8A. Subsequently, the numerical data from these forms will be entered electronically into the system. This technology is designed to compare the two records—the photographic image and the electronic entry—and automatically flag any identified discrepancies before the results are transmitted to the INEC Result Viewing portal (IReV).

Mr. Bayode acknowledged a potential challenge where unclear handwriting on the physical forms could lead to misinterpretation by the system. In such instances, he clarified that the presiding officer retains the authority to proceed with the process after personally reviewing and addressing the flagged discrepancy. Crucially, he emphasized that the paper Form EC8A maintains its status as the official polling-unit record. This explanation, as reported by PREMIUM TIMES, did not characterize the proposed result checks as involving artificial intelligence, a term used by Mr. Atiku's campaign.

The commission has indicated that the November 28 mock exercise is intended to test both accreditation procedures and the electronic transmission of results across the country. However, it remains unconfirmed whether every feature of the proposed system will be fully implemented and tested during this upcoming exercise. The clarity on the legal status of physical Form EC8A versus electronic records and the process for resolving flagged discrepancies will be critical for future election petitions and challenges to results.

Broader Political Landscape and Legal Challenges

Amidst these calls for greater transparency in INEC's technological processes, the commission is also navigating a complex political landscape marked by internal party disputes and shifting alliances. The African Democratic Congress (ADC), for instance, faces internal divisions, with a rival faction, led by Nafiu Bala Gombe, making its own demands on INEC. Rufus Ikanmi, chairman of this faction's Board of Trustees, publicly urged the commission to enforce the Federal High Court judgment delivered by Justice Peter Lifu on November 5. This judgment had invalidated Atiku Abubakar's presidential nomination under the ADC. Mr. Ikanmi's faction specifically requested the removal of David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola from INEC's leadership records and the delisting of candidates submitted by the opposing ADC group, as reported by Blueprint. Separately, the ADC campaign council had requested INEC to postpone the November 28 mock exercise, citing a letter that mandated political parties to submit their agents' names by November 18.

Concurrently, the political arena witnessed the All Progressives Grand Alliance (APGA) publicly reaffirming its support for President Bola Tinubu. This endorsement occurred at a joint rally held with the All Progressives Congress (APC) in Awka. During the event, Anambra State Governor Chukwuma Soludo presented the APGA flag to Vice-President Kashim Shettima, who accepted it on behalf of President Tinubu, solidifying APGA's backing for the APC presidential ticket. This rally took place just one day before Peter Obi, the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) candidate, was scheduled to host a town hall meeting in Onitsha, and against the backdrop of an ongoing controversy concerning a billboard featuring Mr. Obi. The confluence of these events underscores the heightened scrutiny and diverse pressures facing INEC as it prepares for future electoral processes and seeks to uphold election integrity.

Practical Implications

Lawyers advising political parties or involved in election litigation should closely monitor INEC's response to Atiku's audit demand and its final procedures for result verification. The clarity on the legal status of physical Form EC8A versus electronic records and the process for resolving flagged discrepancies will be critical for future election petitions and challenges to results.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Nigerian Tribune, PREMIUM TIMES, and Blueprint.

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Nigeria

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.