
Curt McDaniel: AI Expertise In-House Legal Ops Crucial for Corporate Legal
Summary
- The integration of AI into corporate legal functions necessitates a strategic decision on where specialized AI expertise should reside within the legal department.
- Legal Operations is increasingly seen as the optimal hub for AI expertise due to its deep understanding of legal workflows and processes.
- AI is an enterprise-wide technology, requiring legal departments to integrate their AI initiatives with broader company technology strategies to avoid siloed implementations.
- Former Chief Legal Officer Curt McDaniel successfully used his department's budget to hire a legal data scientist, reporting to Legal Ops, to analyze legal data for process improvement when central IT did not prioritize the role.
- Effective AI implementation in legal should prioritize "how work should be done" by focusing on existing people and processes, rather than solely on technology capabilities.
Defining AI Expertise in Corporate Legal Departments
The distinct advantage of Legal Operations in driving in-house counsel AI implementation stems from its unparalleled understanding of the legal department's internal workings.
The integration of artificial intelligence into corporate legal functions presents a critical strategic question for in-house counsel and compliance officers: where should the specialized AI expertise reside within the legal department? This ongoing discussion has been a focal point for industry veterans, including Curt McDaniel, who served as Chief Legal Officer at Ferring Pharmaceuticals for six years during his 19-year tenure, leading significant advancements in the global legal function's service delivery, and retired in 2025. Both McDaniel and the author agree that AI initiatives must be woven into a broader corporate legal department AI strategy, rather than being treated as isolated technological projects.
Initially, there was a divergence in views regarding the specific placement of AI capabilities. The author advocates for Legal Operations to potentially become the primary hub for AI expertise within the legal department. McDaniel's perspective has evolved, now emphasizing the necessity for deep AI expertise within an in-house legal team, with Legal Operations taking the lead role, complemented by lawyers possessing a foundational understanding of AI. This consensus highlights the growing recognition of the legal operations AI role as central to successful in-house counsel AI implementation.
Integrating Legal AI into the Enterprise Landscape
A significant challenge in establishing AI expertise in-house legal ops is ensuring that legal technology initiatives do not become isolated from the broader organizational infrastructure. Curt McDaniel raises a crucial point: AI is not an exclusive domain for legal departments; it is an enterprise-wide technology. Companies typically already possess dedicated teams responsible for technology, data governance, security protocols, privacy regulations, and financial oversight—all of which are vital for the responsible deployment of AI solutions. Consequently, the legal department cannot independently construct its own "AI universe."
Past experiences with legal technology have shown the pitfalls of such siloed approaches. Departments have acquired solutions only to discover later that they conflict with the company's existing technology architecture, introduce security or integration issues, or duplicate capabilities already present elsewhere in the organization. The inherent nature of AI, with its reliance on shared underlying infrastructure, amplifies these risks. McDaniel observed during his time as Chief Legal Officer that legal departments often do not receive priority for technology investments or IT expertise from a company-wide perspective, with areas like Research & Development and Manufacturing typically commanding more funding and attention. To circumvent this, he utilized his department's own budget for IT expertise, while meticulously coordinating with central IT and other affected groups to ensure alignment. This proactive approach is essential for effective legal tech AI management.
Legal Operations' Unique Understanding of Workflows
The distinct advantage of Legal Operations in driving in-house counsel AI implementation stems from its unparalleled understanding of the legal department's internal workings. While IT teams excel in technological understanding, data teams manage architectural complexities, and security teams mitigate risks, none possess the intimate knowledge of legal workflows that Legal Operations does. This includes a deep insight into how matters progress, where approvals are required, common bottlenecks, processes ripe for standardization, tasks demanding legal judgment, and areas where lawyers dedicate time to non-legal work.
This granular understanding is indispensable when determining the most appropriate applications for AI within the legal function. The fundamental question should not revolve around "What can this technology do?" but rather, "How should this work be accomplished?" This approach necessitates a focus on existing people and processes as the starting point for any AI integration. An illustrative example from Ferring Pharmaceuticals demonstrates this principle: the legal team, which collected extensive data through tools like a Contract Lifecycle Management (CLM) system and an e-billing/matter management platform, sought to analyze this data to continuously refine its processes. When the central IT department did not prioritize the need for a data scientist, Legal Operations took the initiative. They hired a legal data scientist using their own budget, ensuring the role reported to Legal Ops while coordinating with IT for compliance with company policies. They informed IT and HR, provided their rationale, and offered to cover the costs. This led to the successful creation of a data lake within the company's IT structure, with all parties in agreement, showcasing how AI expertise in-house legal ops can bridge gaps and drive innovation.
Practical Implications
In-house counsel and compliance officers should strategically assess where AI expertise will reside within their legal department, considering Legal Operations as a key driver due to its understanding of legal workflows. This involves planning for resource allocation, defining roles, and ensuring integration with broader enterprise technology strategies to avoid siloed implementations and maximize efficiency.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
