
AG Szpunar Opinion: Belgian Data Retention Law May Be Validated
Summary
- Advocate General Szpunar issued an opinion on September 3, 2026, in case C-661/24, Académie Fiscale and Others, concerning Belgian data retention law.
- The case questions the compliance of Belgium's 2022 data retention regime with European Union privacy standards.
- Belgium's two previous data retention laws were annulled by the CJEU in 2014 and 2020.
- The current CJEU case focuses on retention obligations and permissions for internet companies to detect fraud or security breaches.
- The Advocate General's opinion is seen as potentially paving the way for broader data retention measures within the EU.
Advocate General's Stance on Belgian Data Retention
The Advocate General's perspective suggests a potential validation of broader data retention regimes, which could significantly impact compliance obligations and the legality of national data retention laws across member states.
On September 3, 2026, Advocate General (AG) Szpunar of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered his opinion in case C-661/24, known as Académie Fiscale and Others. This significant opinion addresses the conformity of Belgium's most recent data retention framework with established EU privacy standards. The AG's perspective has been interpreted as potentially endorsing more extensive data retention schemes, which could have far-reaching implications for compliance requirements and the legality of national data retention laws throughout the European Union.
Lawyers advising telecommunication and internet service providers within the EU should closely monitor the CJEU's forthcoming judgment in C-661/24. The Advocate General's opinion suggests a potential validation of broader data retention regimes, which could significantly impact compliance obligations and the legality of national data retention laws across member states. This development could reshape the landscape for how data is collected and stored by these entities, necessitating a re-evaluation of current practices.
The case specifically scrutinizes the Belgian data retention law enacted in 2022, which has faced a legal challenge from Belgian civil society organizations, including Liga voor Mensenrechten, an EDRi member. The AG's opinion in this context is crucial as it provides a preliminary legal assessment that often influences the final ruling of the CJEU, thus setting a potential precedent for EU data retention standards.
Belgium's Troubled History with Data Retention
Belgium has a contentious history concerning its data retention legislation, with previous attempts to implement such laws meeting significant legal hurdles. The CJEU previously annulled two of Belgium's earlier data retention laws, first in 2014 and again in 2020, highlighting a consistent struggle to align national provisions with stringent EU privacy standards.
The current 2022 Belgian data retention law represents the nation's latest effort to establish a legal framework for data retention. Despite the repeated setbacks, this new legislation is now also under scrutiny, demonstrating the ongoing tension between national security interests and fundamental rights to privacy within the EU legal framework.
Scope of the Current Legal Challenge
In 2024, the Belgian Constitutional Court largely upheld the new data retention legal framework, including specific provisions that permit targeted data retention based on geographical areas. However, the practical application of this 'targeted' approach has been questioned, as the criteria adopted by the government effectively extend coverage to nearly the entire country, rendering the targeting less precise than its designation suggests.
Notably, the case currently before the CJEU will not delve into the specifics of this 'targeted' retention aspect. Instead, the CJEU's examination is confined to articles within the Belgian law that establish retention obligations and grant permissions for internet companies to retain data for the purpose of detecting fraud or security breaches on their networks or services. This narrow focus means the CJEU will miss an opportunity to thoroughly assess one of the first attempts by a Member State to implement its jurisprudence requiring targeted retention for traffic and location data.
Implications for EU Privacy Standards
The Advocate General's opinion, particularly its perceived openness to broader data retention measures, signals a critical juncture for EU privacy standards. Should the CJEU adopt a similar stance, it could lead to a reinterpretation of the strict conditions previously imposed on data retention by the Court, potentially allowing member states more latitude in their national laws.
This development is particularly relevant for the ongoing debate surrounding the balance between security imperatives and individual privacy rights across the EU. The final judgment in Académie Fiscale and Others C-661/24 will therefore be a key indicator of the future direction of EU data retention policy and its impact on both citizens and telecommunications providers.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising telecom and internet companies in the EU should closely monitor the CJEU's final judgment in C-661/24, as the Advocate General's opinion suggests a potential validation of broader data retention regimes, which could significantly impact compliance obligations and the legality of national data retention laws across member states.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in European Union
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
