
Sanele Dlamini NLC Dismissal Upheld by CCMA: Former COO Loses Appeal
Summary
- Former NLC acting COO Sanele Dlamini failed his CCMA challenge against his dismissal for lottery grant corruption.
- CCMA Commissioner Hilda Grobler ruled Dlamini's dismissal was both procedurally and substantively fair, rejecting his claims of innocence.
- Dlamini was found guilty of approving questionable grants, providing dishonest recommendations, and dereliction of duty related to projects like Phumelela Educational Training Projects and the Motheo Sports and Entertainment Foundation.
- The Special Tribunal previously froze Dlamini's pension and ordered him and others to repay R6 million for an unbuilt Soweto sports complex.
- Commissioner Grobler found Dlamini to be a "poor witness" whose testimony was "improbable" and designed to shift blame.
What Happened
Based on a balance of probabilities, Grobler concluded that Dlamini was indeed guilty of the four charges and that dismissal was the appropriate sanction.
Sanele Dlamini, the former acting chief operating officer of the National Lotteries Commission (NLC), has been unsuccessful in his second attempt to overturn his dismissal. His challenge before the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) concluded with Commissioner Hilda Grobler upholding the NLC's decision to terminate his employment. Dlamini was among several NLC officials implicated in alleged lottery grant corruption and subsequently dismissed in 2024 following internal disciplinary proceedings.
The CCMA proceedings, which spanned 17 days between May 2025 and October this year, culminated in a lengthy ruling issued in early November. Commissioner Grobler explicitly rejected Dlamini's assertions of innocence, determining that his dismissal was both procedurally and substantively fair. Dlamini had been suspended in December 2023 and faced six charges, ultimately being found guilty on four. His initial dismissal occurred in September 2024, and an internal appeal was dismissed in March 2025.
The charges on which Dlamini was found guilty primarily concerned his role in approving questionable grant payments, providing dishonest recommendations, and demonstrating dereliction of duty, particularly regarding grant funding processes. These allegations specifically involved two projects: Phumelela Educational Training Projects, which received nearly R9.6 million in grant funding between 2014 and 2018, and the Motheo Sports and Entertainment Foundation's Soweto sports complex. The latter project received an initial R3 million, followed by an additional R3 million, both signed off by Dlamini, despite no construction progress on site. Furthermore, Dlamini was found guilty of failing to provide information requested by the Auditor-General.
Broader Accountability and Legal Actions
Beyond the CCMA ruling, Dlamini has faced additional legal repercussions stemming from the extensive investigations into National Lotteries Commission corruption. In June 2025, the Special Tribunal granted an urgent interdict in favor of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU), leading to the freezing of Dlamini’s pension. This action underscored the multi-agency approach to recovering public funds and holding implicated individuals accountable.
Further demonstrating the severity of the allegations and the commitment to restitution, the Special Tribunal issued another order in July this year. This ruling mandated Dlamini and other implicated parties to repay R6 million. This amount directly relates to the funds the NLC had allocated for the construction of the aforementioned sports complex in Soweto, a project that was never completed despite the significant grants disbursed. These legal actions highlight the ongoing efforts to address South Africa lottery grant fraud and ensure financial accountability.
The Commissioner's Findings
In her detailed ruling, CCMA Commissioner Hilda Grobler provided a critical assessment of the evidence presented during the protracted hearing. She found the two witnesses presented by the NLC—investigators from its internal audit unit and the SIU, who were instrumental in the initial investigation of the awards—to be "reasoned and persuasive." Conversely, Grobler characterized Dlamini’s own accounts as "improbable," at times bordering on the "absurd," and described him as a "poor witness."
Grobler noted that Dlamini frequently avoided answering direct questions during cross-examination, "embroidered" his responses, and presented contradictory evidence. She also highlighted that his own witnesses contradicted his testimony. The Commissioner identified a "clear pattern" in Dlamini's responses, which she concluded were designed to "exonerate him by shifting the blame or the responsibility or the steps that were taken to others." This, she stated, was intended to create the impression that he had committed no wrongdoing and was merely bearing the consequences of others' actions. Based on a balance of probabilities, Grobler concluded that Dlamini was indeed guilty of the four charges and that dismissal was the appropriate sanction. Regarding procedural fairness, Dlamini had argued unfair treatment because his disciplinary and appeal hearings were conducted "on the papers." However, Grobler confirmed that Dlamini, despite being medically unfit to attend his disciplinary hearing, was legally represented throughout the process and afforded a full and fair opportunity to present his case.
Practical Implications
This case reinforces that South African employers, particularly public entities, can successfully defend dismissals for serious misconduct like corruption at the CCMA, provided disciplinary procedures are procedurally and substantively fair. It also highlights the multi-agency approach (SIU, Special Tribunal, CCMA) in pursuing accountability for public funds, including freezing pensions and ordering repayment.
Source
Source: Original reporting via GroundUp
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
