
redT: 10th Circuit Hears Denver Affordable Housing Appeal Over Takings
Summary
- Colorado developer redT is appealing to the 10th Circuit to restore its lawsuit against Denver's affordable housing program.
- Denver's ordinance requires developers to pay linkage fees or set aside 10% of units at below-market rates for 99 years.
- redT claims the program constitutes an unconstitutional taking, citing specific fees of $24,962 and $44,917 for its projects.
- A U.S. District Judge previously dismissed redT's lawsuit, leading to the current appeal.
- 10th Circuit judges questioned Denver's city attorney on whether the program deprives developers of property rights and constitutes a taking.
The Developer's Challenge
U.S. Circuit Judge Harris Hartz directly challenged the city's attorney, asserting that a restriction running with the land inherently constitutes a taking.
Colorado real estate developer redT has brought a significant challenge against the City and County of Denver's affordable housing program, appealing to the 10th Circuit to reinstate its lawsuit. The developer contends that Denver's ordinance, which mandates either substantial fees or the dedication of a portion of new construction for below-market housing, imposes an undue burden that threatens the viability of "attainably priced," LEED-certified homes. This legal action, known as the redT development lawsuit, was initially filed in May 2025, alleging that the city's requirements amount to an unconstitutional taking of private property.
Denver's program requires developers to pay "linkage fees" on new construction, ranging from $1.99 to $7.22 per square foot. Alternatively, developers can avoid these fees by setting aside 10% of a project's units to be sold at below-market rates for a period of 99 years. redT highlighted specific financial impacts, noting that fees for one property totaled $24,962, while another fourplex would incur $44,917 in fees. The developer's attorney, David Deerson of the Pacific Legal Foundation, stated that Denver is withholding a construction permit from redT until $70,000 in fees are paid. U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer, a George W. Bush appointee, previously granted Denver's motion to dismiss the case in March, prompting redT's current redT Denver affordable housing appeal.
Legal Arguments and Judicial Scrutiny
At the heart of the 10th Circuit Denver housing takings case is the fundamental question of whether Denver's affordable housing ordinance constitutes an unconstitutional taking under the Fifth Amendment. redT argues that the program, described as an "unsustainable paradox in land use extractions law," forces developers to surrender property value without just compensation. City attorney Adam Hernandez, representing Denver, countered this by characterizing the program as a restrictive covenant, asserting it does not rise to the level of a government taking.
During the appellate proceedings, the judges of the 10th Circuit expressed skepticism regarding Denver's position. U.S. Circuit Judge Richard Federico, a Joe Biden appointee, invoked the "bundle of sticks" metaphor for property rights, questioning whether preventing a developer from selling a unit on the open market for its highest value effectively deprives them of the right to dispose of property. U.S. Circuit Judge Joel Carson, a Donald Trump appointee, posed a hypothetical about being forced to give away a tenth home if building nine for his children, illustrating the perceived burden. Furthermore, Judge Carson dismissed the city's argument that the ordinance could be changed, stating, "We can talk about changing it, but by the time you change the law, it’s too late. You changing the law five years from now has nothing to do with this case."
The most direct challenge came from U.S. Circuit Judge Harris Hartz, a George W. Bush appointee, who pressed Hernandez to acknowledge the program as a taking. U.S. Circuit Judge Harris Hartz directly challenged the city's attorney, asserting that a restriction running with the land inherently constitutes a taking. He added, "You can defend this with your analysis, you can say it’s necessary and justified, but to say it’s not a taking, I don’t understand how you can do that." This line of questioning underscores the court's focus on the nature of the restriction and its impact on property rights in the Denver linkage fees challenge.
Broader Implications for Development
The outcome of the redT Denver affordable housing appeal before the 10th Circuit carries significant implications for municipalities nationwide grappling with housing affordability and for real estate developers operating under similar ordinances. A ruling in favor of redT could establish a critical precedent regarding the constitutionality of mandatory affordable housing set-asides and linkage fees, potentially reshaping how cities implement such programs. Conversely, a decision upholding Denver's ordinance would reinforce the ability of local governments to impose these requirements as a condition for development.
This case directly addresses the boundaries of the Takings Clause in the context of land use regulation, particularly concerning exactions and impact fees. The judges' pointed questions suggest a deep consideration of whether Denver's program crosses the line from a permissible regulation into an unconstitutional taking Denver ordinance. The 10th Circuit's eventual decision will provide crucial guidance on the extent to which local governments can compel private developers to contribute to public policy goals, such as affordable housing, without infringing upon constitutional property rights.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising real estate developers or municipalities should closely monitor the 10th Circuit's decision in *redT v. Denver* as it will provide critical precedent on the constitutionality of affordable housing linkage fees and mandatory set-asides under the Takings Clause, potentially impacting future development agreements and municipal ordinances.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
