
Ninth Circuit: San Diego CCW Lawsuit Revived for Shilling
Summary
- A federal appeals court revived Kenneth Shilling's lawsuit against San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez over the revocation of his concealed carry weapon license.
- Shilling's license was revoked in December 2023 based on a 'good moral character' clause due to his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club.
- The Ninth Circuit found the lower court erred by misunderstanding that First Amendment free association rights can be infringed in varied ways, not just by preventing group participation.
- The appellate panel determined Sheriff Martinez acted as a policymaker in defining the county-specific criteria for revocation, which was not mandated by state law.
- California's 'good moral character' requirement was replaced with more objective criteria in January 2024, following the Supreme Court's *Bruen* decision.
Ninth Circuit Revives CCW Challenge
This ruling signals increased scrutiny on discretionary 'good moral character' clauses in concealed carry weapon (CCW) licensing, particularly when based on an applicant's association with a group.
A federal appeals court has breathed new life into a lawsuit brought by a Southern California man, Kenneth Shilling, who alleges that San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez unlawfully revoked his concealed carry weapon (CCW) license. The Ninth Circuit San Diego CCW lawsuit revived earlier this week, overturning a lower court's dismissal of Shilling's claims against both Sheriff Martinez and San Diego County. At the heart of the dispute is Shilling's membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, which Sheriff Martinez reportedly considers a criminal street gang.
Shilling initially obtained his concealed carry license in June 2022, under the tenure of the previous sheriff. However, his license was subsequently revoked by Sheriff Martinez in December 2023. The basis for this revocation was a clause within the California penal code that mandates applicants possess "good moral character." Shilling, a resident of Chula Vista and a longtime employee of the Chula Vista Elementary School District, maintains a clean criminal record, according to the appellate panel.
First Amendment Association Rights at Issue
The unanimous decision, penned by U.S. Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay, determined that Shilling had adequately demonstrated an infringement upon his First Amendment right to free association, which he argued occurred when the sheriff deprived him of his Second Amendment right to carry a concealed weapon. Judge Bumatay, a Donald Trump appointee, clarified that the district court had misconstrued the scope of free association rights. The lower court had erroneously suggested that Shilling needed to prove the revocation actively prevented him from associating with the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club or participating in its activities.
Judge Bumatay emphasized that while preventing participation is one potential way to violate the First Amendment, the right to free association can be compromised in numerous other forms. He was joined in this ruling by U.S. Circuit Judge Kenneth Lee, also a Trump appointee, and U.S. Circuit Judge Jennifer Sung, a Joe Biden appointee. Shilling's attorney, Gary Gorski, underscored the significance of the Bill of Rights prevailing over political considerations in this context.
Scrutiny on Discretionary 'Good Moral Character' Clauses
A critical aspect of the Ninth Circuit's ruling is its finding that Sheriff Martinez acted as a policymaker, rather than merely a state official, when she revoked Shilling's license based on the "good moral character" requirement. The panel noted that no state law explicitly mandated the specific, county-level definition used by San Diego County to deem association with the Boozefighters a disqualifying factor for a California concealed carry license challenge. This distinction highlights that San Diego County, not the state of California, established this particular criterion for CCW revocation.
This ruling signals increased scrutiny on discretionary 'good moral character' clauses in concealed carry weapon (CCW) licensing, particularly when based on an applicant's association with a group. The state's penal code provision regarding "good moral character" was, in fact, replaced with more objective and clearly defined criteria in January 2024, shortly after Shilling's license was revoked. This legislative change followed the landmark Supreme Court decision in *New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen*, which reshaped the landscape for concealed carry regulations nationwide. Shilling filed his lawsuit in June 2024, asserting that the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, founded in 1946 by World War II veterans, is primarily involved in charitable endeavors and has never identified as an outlaw motorcycle gang.
Practical Implications
This ruling signals increased scrutiny on discretionary 'good moral character' clauses in concealed carry weapon (CCW) licensing, particularly when based on an applicant's association with a group. Lawyers should advise clients on the evolving legal landscape for CCW applications and revocations, preparing for potential First Amendment challenges against subjective criteria, especially those not explicitly mandated by state law.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
