
Ninth Circuit: Questions ICE Knock-and-Talk Immigration Arrest Policy Legality
Summary
- A Ninth Circuit panel is reviewing a lower court's ban on ICE's "knock-and-talk" immigration arrest policy.
- The lower court ruled in 2025 that ICE requires a judicial warrant, not just an administrative one, to make arrests during these operations.
- Judges expressed skepticism about the government's argument that administrative warrants are sufficient for home entry and arrest.
- Immigrant groups argue that the policy violates Fourth Amendment rights by allowing home entry with intent to arrest without a judicial warrant.
- The court also considered arguments regarding the plaintiffs' legal standing to challenge the policy.
Judicial Scrutiny of ICE's "Knock-and-Talk" Policy
The Ninth Circuit's ultimate decision on this US immigration arrest policy will significantly shape future ICE home entry rights and Fourth Amendment immigration enforcement practices.
A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently heard arguments concerning the legality of a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) "knock-and-talk" policy, which a lower court previously prohibited. This policy, originating from the Los Angeles Field Office, involves immigration officers approaching individuals' homes to engage them, often leading to arrests. The federal government is appealing a 2025 ruling that determined ICE agents cannot use this method to effect an arrest without first obtaining a judicial warrant.
The appellate judges expressed considerable skepticism regarding the government's position during the proceedings. U.S. Circuit Judge Milan Smith Jr. underscored that if an officer's explicit intention is to make an arrest, the "knock-and-talk" approach is inappropriate, emphasizing the necessity of a proper warrant. Similarly, U.S. Circuit Judge Danielle Forrest questioned the extent of an officer's implied license to enter private property, suggesting it should not exceed that of an ordinary member of the public. The panel has taken the complex matter under submission for further deliberation.
Competing Legal Interpretations of Home Entry and Arrest
The core of the dispute revolves around the Fourth Amendment's protections against unreasonable searches and seizures, particularly concerning home entries and arrests without judicial authorization. Deputy Assistant Attorney General Drew Ensign, representing the government, contended that the authority for administrative warrants, which can lead to arrests, has historical roots dating back to 1797. Ensign asserted that special rules apply to immigration enforcement, making these administrative warrants constitutionally permissible and not violative of the Fourth Amendment, as they allow officers to seek consent for property entry to enforce immigration laws.
However, Judge Forrest highlighted that while an officer might have an implied license to gather information, the government's own evidence indicated that arrests, not just information gathering, were occurring. Jeremy Kreisberg, counsel for the immigrant groups, countered the government's arguments, stressing that the Fourth Amendment fundamentally requires a judicial warrant for law enforcement to enter a home and make an arrest. He argued that the government's attempt to reinstate the "knock-and-talk" policy lacked a sound legal basis, particularly given the lower court's prior decision to vacate it.
Standing and the Impact on Immigrant Communities
A significant point of contention during the hearing was the issue of standing, which questions whether the immigrant groups had the legal right to bring the lawsuit. Kreisberg argued that the constitutional violation occurs the moment an immigration officer steps onto private property with the intent to arrest, irrespective of whether the resident chooses to answer the door. He emphasized that the government possesses the addresses of individuals assisted by these groups, leading to a legitimate fear among them of being targeted for arrest due to their immigration status.
Judge Forrest articulated a potential government argument, suggesting that individuals could simply choose not to respond to a "knock-and-talk." However, Kreisberg maintained that the violation is in the act of entry with intent to arrest. Ensign, for his part, argued that the plaintiffs needed to specifically identify individuals who had suffered harm to meet the standing requirements, further contending that the immigrant groups themselves lacked standing in the case. The Ninth Circuit's ultimate decision on this US immigration arrest policy will significantly shape future ICE home entry rights and Fourth Amendment immigration enforcement practices.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising non-citizens or immigrant groups must monitor the Ninth Circuit's decision on the 'knock-and-talk' policy, as its reinstatement or permanent prohibition will directly impact the legality of immigration arrests and home entries without judicial warrants, requiring updated advice to clients on their constitutional rights.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
