New York Appellate Division Rules in Desai v. Ninety Five Wall St. LLC

On October 22, 2026, the Appellate Division, First Department, in New York, decided and entered an appeal in the case of *Desai v. Ninety Five Wall St. LLC*, involving Sagar Desai as Plaintiff-Appellant and Ninety Five Wall Street LLC et al. as Defendants-Respondents. This decision, identified as 2026 NY Slip Op 06198, was published by the New York State Law Reporting Bureau and is noted as uncorrected and subject to revision before its final publication in the Official Reports. The excerpt indicates that Justice Manzanet-Daniels was among the justices presiding over the matter, which carries Index No. 653312/24 and Appeal No. 7317.

This appellate decision, while its specific holding is not detailed in the excerpt, is legally significant as it contributes to the body of New York state common law. Decisions from the Appellate Division, an intermediate appellate court, are binding on lower courts within its geographic department and can clarify or establish precedent on various legal issues. For practitioners, tracking such decisions is crucial for understanding the evolving legal landscape, particularly in areas of law that might be implicated by disputes involving real estate entities or corporate defendants, given the names of the parties involved. The fact that it is an appeal means a lower court's decision was reviewed, potentially leading to affirmation, modification, or reversal.

The legal context for this case is the New York State court system, where the Appellate Division, First Department, serves as a critical appellate body for cases originating in Manhattan and the Bronx. Its authority to publish decisions pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431 underscores the precedential value of its rulings once finalized. The mention of a