
M&G Investments: Spar General Meeting Requisition for 5 New Directors
Summary
- M&G Investments, holding over 14% of Spar, has requisitioned a general meeting to elect five new directors.
- Nominees include Phil Roux, Angelo Swartz, Anton Wentzel, George Skoutellas, and Omnichand Lalbahadur.
- Spar's board will issue a meeting notice within 10 business days, with the meeting anticipated within 25 business days, in compliance with the Companies Act and JSE rules.
- All director nominees will undergo fit-and-proper and independence assessments, with results provided to shareholders before the vote.
- This action follows ongoing conflicts over Spar's leadership, previous board resignations, and a significant decline in the company's share price.
Shareholder Action Initiated
M&G Investments, a significant shareholder holding more than 14% of Spar's share capital, has formally requested a general meeting.
M&G Investments, a significant shareholder holding more than 14% of Spar's share capital, has formally requested a general meeting. The primary objective of this meeting is to facilitate the election of five new directors to the company's board.
The proposed slate of nominees includes Phil Roux, a turnaround specialist who has garnered support from Spar retailers, and Angelo Swartz, the former CEO. Other individuals put forward for board positions are Anton Wentzel, Spar retailer George Skoutellas, and Omnichand Lalbahadur. This move by M&G Investments signals a clear intent to influence the strategic direction and governance of the wholesaler.
Board Response and Procedural Compliance
In response to M&G's requisition, Spar's board has affirmed its commitment to upholding shareholders' rights to call a general meeting. The company has stated it will issue a formal notice for the meeting within 10 business days, adhering strictly to the provisions of the Companies Act, its own memorandum of incorporation, and the JSE listings requirements.
It is anticipated that the general meeting will take place within 25 business days following the issuance of the notice. Prior to the meeting, each nominated director will undergo comprehensive fit-and-proper and independence assessments, consistent with the standards applied to all existing board members. The outcomes of these evaluations will be disclosed to shareholders before they cast their votes, with a fit-and-proper assessment already completed for Phil Roux.
Context of Boardroom Tensions
This latest development unfolds against a backdrop of ongoing conflict concerning Spar's leadership and executive structure, particularly between the company and the Spar Guild. The Guild had previously advocated for Phil Roux to assume the role of chair, expressing this preference in a letter to the board on September 10. Earlier, the Guild had also called for the resignation of former chair Mike Bosman, who, along with deputy chair Shirley Zinn, subsequently stepped down on August 17.
Phil Roux had previously been offered a non-executive director position by Spar, but he declined the offer after his undisclosed conditions were not met. Lwazi Koyana, the permanent chair of the Spar Group, who has served on the board since 2019, acknowledged the board's disciplined process in the interest of all shareholders and the company's long-term sustainability. He emphasized the board's respect for shareholders' right to propose directors and committed to assessing all nominees consistently, looking forward to constructive engagement.
Performance and Strategic Challenges
The current board dynamics are set against a challenging period for Spar, marked by a significant decline in its share price, which has fallen nearly 75% over the past five years. The company has faced several strategic hurdles, including costly exits from operations in Switzerland and Poland, as well as a problematic implementation of SAP software at its largest KwaZulu-Natal distribution center. Furthermore, Spar's convenience retail model is under increasing pressure from the rise of on-demand delivery services.
Lwazi Koyana's tenure on the board has spanned these significant events. Another recently appointed non-executive director, Pattison, brings experience from struggling retailers, having served on the board of Pick n Pay until late October, been CEO at Edgars during its business rescue, and CEO of Massmart in 2011 when it sold a stake to Walmart. These appointments and the shareholder requisition highlight a critical juncture for Spar as it navigates its corporate governance and operational challenges.
Practical Implications
This case highlights the procedural requirements under the South African Companies Act and JSE listings rules for shareholder-requisitioned general meetings and director nominations. Lawyers should advise clients on their rights and obligations regarding such requisitions, including timelines for issuing notices and conducting fit-and-proper assessments for proposed directors, especially in situations of shareholder activism.
Source
Source: Original reporting via Moneyweb
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
