Pretoria High Court: Lucky Montana Provisional Sequestration by SARS Over R47 Million Tax Debt
Case Law

Pretoria High Court: Lucky Montana Provisional Sequestration by SARS Over R47 Million Tax Debt

South Africa·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 5 min read

Summary

  • Former PRASA CEO Lucky Montana's joint estate with his wife, Sefora Devereaux Letsoalo, has been provisionally sequestrated by the Pretoria High Court.
  • The order, granted at the request of SARS, means Mr. Montana immediately loses control over his financial affairs due to an alleged R47 million tax debt.
  • The dispute stems from a 2020 SARS audit that found R38.8 million in under-declared income and capital gains, leading to a R15.6 million tax liability and a 200% penalty.
  • Mr. Montana disputed the debt, refused to cooperate with the audit beyond five years, and failed to lodge a valid objection to SARS's findings.
  • The sequestration application proceeded after warrants of execution failed to recover sufficient assets, and Mr. Montana's late disclosure of his marriage in community of property complicated the proceedings.

Court Orders Provisional Sequestration

The court's decision means that Mr. Montana immediately loses control over his financial affairs, a significant consequence that also extends to his wife due to their marriage in community of property.

A recent ruling by Judge MJ Teffo in the Pretoria High Court has resulted in the provisional sequestration of the joint estate belonging to former Passenger Rail Agency (PRASA) chief, Lucky Montana, and his wife, Sefora Devereaux Letsoalo. This significant legal development stems from an application brought by the South African Revenue Service (SARS), which alleges Mr. Montana owes approximately R47 million in unpaid taxes.

The court's decision means that Mr. Montana immediately loses control over his financial affairs, a significant consequence that also extends to his wife due to their marriage in community of property. Should this provisional order be made final following a court appearance scheduled for February next year, a trustee will be appointed to oversee the complete winding up of their estate.

This action by SARS highlights a long-standing dispute with the former PRASA CEO regarding his tax obligations. The tax authority's aggressive pursuit of the outstanding debt has culminated in this provisional sequestration, marking a critical juncture in Mr. Montana's financial and legal challenges.

The Tax Dispute's Long History

The legal battle between Lucky Montana and SARS has a protracted and complex history, which Judge Teffo described as a "long and unhappy procedural history." The dispute began in November 2020 when SARS initiated an audit of Mr. Montana's tax affairs spanning the years 2009 to 2019. By July 2021, the audit findings proposed adjustments for under-declared income and capital gains amounting to approximately R38.8 million, which translated to a tax liability of about R15.6 million, further compounded by a 200% penalty.

Following these findings, Mr. Montana publicly disputed the amount, asserting he owed "not a cent" and accusing SARS of conducting a "witchhunt." He also refused to cooperate with any audit extending beyond a five-year period. In response, SARS issued a "finalisation of audit letter" in April 2022, imposing a 200% "understatement penalty," citing his conduct as indicative of "intentional tax evasion and obstructive" behavior. Mr. Montana, who resigned as an MP for the MK Party in December 2025, never lodged a valid objection to this audit outcome.

By July 2022, SARS issued a final demand letter, requiring payment of nearly R45 million within ten business days. Subsequently, the tax authority filed a certified statement with the court registrar, which legally carries the weight of a civil judgment. Despite warrants of execution being issued, the sheriff was unable to locate sufficient assets at three of Mr. Montana's properties to satisfy the debt, leading SARS to initiate the sequestration application in May 2023.

Procedural Maneuvers and Marital Disclosure

The sequestration application was initially set to be heard on the unopposed roll in November 2025 but faced an unexpected delay. Just two days prior to the scheduled hearing, Mr. Montana submitted a lengthy answering affidavit. In this document, he disclosed for the first time that he had married Sefora Devereaux Letsoalo in November 2023, under a community of property regime.

This late disclosure prompted SARS to seek an amendment to its papers to include Ms. Letsoalo in the sequestration proceedings, an application that Mr. Montana opposed. He also sought condonation for the extremely late filing of his answering affidavit, which was due on April 26, 2024, but was only delivered on November 17, 2025. Judge Teffo characterized this delay as "grossly inordinate" and noted, as another judge had previously observed, that it indicated Mr. Montana was "playing for time." The judge also acknowledged the merit in SARS's contention that the affidavit was a "tactical measure."

Despite these concerns, Judge Teffo ultimately granted condonation, emphasizing that considering the far-reaching consequences of sequestration, it was in the interests of justice to review the affidavit's contents. Mr. Montana had argued that the initial failure to cite Ms. Letsoalo was "fatal" to the application and, paradoxically, opposed her joinder by claiming she lacked a direct and substantial interest in the matter. This legal action follows earlier reports in August this year by GroundUp, detailing proceedings before the Special Tribunal where the Special Investigating Unit secured an order freezing two multi-million rand properties allegedly acquired by Mr. Montana through corrupt activities at the state-owned entity.

Practical Implications

This case underscores SARS's aggressive pursuit of tax non-compliance, even against high-profile individuals, and the severe implications of provisional sequestration, including loss of financial control. Lawyers should advise clients on the critical importance of timely engagement with SARS and the significant financial exposure for spouses married in community of property when one faces substantial tax liabilities or insolvency proceedings.

Source

Source: Original reporting via GroundUp

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in South Africa

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.