
INEC: 2027 Election Results Collation Must Follow Statutory Process
Summary
- INEC has declared that independent election results tabulation cannot replace statutory collation for the 2027 general elections.
- Barrister Festus Okoye of INEC is seeking clarification on the legal framework for electronic transmission of results.
- The Court of Appeal ruled that electronic transmission is not mandatory, creating a "lacuna" in Section 64(4) of the Electoral Act 2022.
- Okoye urged the National Assembly to amend the Electoral Act to explicitly mandate electronic transmission for enhanced transparency.
- The official collation process, governed by Sections 60, 62, and 64 of the Electoral Act 2022, remains the constitutional and statutory method for aggregating results.
What Happened
The Court of Appeal, in its ruling on the case of Labour Party & Anor v. INEC & Ors, interpreted Section 64(4) of the Electoral Act 2022, concluding that the electronic transmission of results is not a mandatory requirement.
The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) has issued a definitive statement asserting that independent tabulation of election results, often conducted by civil society organizations and media, cannot supersede the official statutory collation process. This position is particularly relevant for the upcoming 2027 general elections, with INEC emphasizing that the constitutionally and legally mandated aggregation of votes remains paramount.
Barrister Festus Okoye, a National Commissioner and Chairman of INEC's Information and Voter Education Committee, conveyed this stance during a recent two-day capacity-building workshop. The event, held in Abuja on November 20th and 21st, 2023, was a collaborative effort between the National Institute for Legislative and Democratic Studies (NILDS) and the Kukah Centre, designed to educate journalists on the intricacies of the 2022 Electoral Act and the 2023 General Election.
In addition to clarifying the hierarchy of results processing, Commissioner Okoye also highlighted a pressing need for legislative clarity regarding the electronic transmission of election results. He indicated that INEC is actively seeking a precise interpretation of the legal provisions governing this technological aspect of the electoral process, underscoring its importance for the integrity and efficiency of the 2027 polls.
Legal Framework Under Scrutiny
The legal foundation for the collation of election results in Nigeria is robustly detailed within the Electoral Act 2022, specifically through Sections 60, 62, and 64. These sections mandate a physical, step-by-step aggregation of results, commencing from individual polling units and progressing upwards to the national level. Okoye underscored that this statutory collation is a constitutional and legal requirement, serving as the definitive method for determining election outcomes.
However, the legal landscape surrounding the electronic transmission of results has become significantly more ambiguous following a judicial interpretation. While INEC had previously expressed its intent to utilize electronic transmission to bolster transparency, the Court of Appeal, in its ruling on the case of Labour Party & Anor v. INEC & Ors, interpreted Section 64(4) of the Electoral Act 2022, concluding that the electronic transmission of results is not a mandatory requirement. This judicial pronouncement has, according to Okoye, created a "lacuna" within the existing legal framework.
This legal gap leaves INEC in a state of uncertainty regarding its authority to fully implement electronic transmission for the 2027 general elections. The commission is now awaiting further clarification on whether it can proceed with its plans for electronic transmission despite the Court of Appeal's interpretation. Okoye acknowledged that courts interpret laws as they are written, not as they ideally should be, emphasizing the need for legislative intervention to resolve this ambiguity.
Why It Matters
The current legal uncertainties surrounding electronic transmission, coupled with INEC's firm stance on the primacy of statutory collation, hold significant implications for the conduct and public perception of the 2027 general elections. INEC's appeal to the National Assembly to amend the Electoral Act 2022 is a direct call to address the "lacuna" created by the Court of Appeal's interpretation of Section 64(4). Okoye specifically urged lawmakers to explicitly mandate electronic transmission of results, arguing that such a legislative change would substantially enhance the transparency and overall credibility of Nigeria's electoral system.
A clear and mandatory legal framework for electronic transmission would not only provide INEC with the necessary operational certainty but also significantly boost public confidence in the electoral process. Without such an amendment, the commission faces challenges in fully deploying technological solutions aimed at improving election integrity. Okoye reiterated INEC's ongoing commitment to refining the electoral process, including the strategic integration of technology, and called upon all stakeholders to lend their support to the commission's efforts to ensure free, fair, and credible elections.
The distinction between statutory collation and independent tabulation, as clarified by INEC, also establishes a clear boundary for the roles of various actors in the electoral process. While independent monitoring contributes to oversight, the ultimate legal authority for determining election outcomes rests with the official collation process. This clarification is crucial for managing expectations and ensuring that all parties understand the definitive legal pathway for results in the lead-up to the 2027 polls.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising political parties or involved in election litigation must note INEC's firm stance on statutory collation overriding independent tabulation for 2027, which will shape future electoral disputes. They should also monitor developments regarding the clarification of the legal framework for electronic transmission of results, as this will impact evidence and procedural arguments in upcoming elections.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Nigeria
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
