
ECHR Orders Turkey: Free Can Atalay, Restore Parliamentary Seat
Summary
- The European Court of Human Rights has ordered Turkey to release elected lawmaker Can Atalay and allow him to serve in Parliament.
- Atalay, a human rights defender, was imprisoned over the 2013 Gezi Park protests and sentenced to 18 years in 2022.
- Turkey's Constitutional Court twice ordered his release, but the Court of Cassation refused to comply and upheld his conviction.
- The ECHR found Atalay's imprisonment unlawful and politically motivated, citing the Court of Cassation's defiance of domestic constitutional judgments.
- Experts view this as a severe blow to democratic rights and judicial independence in Turkey, with concerns about the non-enforcement of international rulings.
What Happened
The defiance shown by the Court of Cassation Turkey Atalay case against both the Turkish Constitutional Court and now the ECHR highlights a troubling pattern.
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has recently mandated Turkey to release elected lawmaker Şerafettin Can Atalay, asserting his right to serve in Parliament. This decision, issued on Tuesday, follows a protracted legal battle for Atalay, a lawyer and human rights advocate who was imprisoned in connection with the 2013 Gezi Park protests. Despite winning a parliamentary seat in May 2023 while his appeal was pending, and securing two separate release orders from Turkey's own Constitutional Court, Atalay has remained incarcerated. His continued detention and his removal from Parliament in January 2024 (a move later declared 'null and void' by Turkey's Constitutional Court but not implemented), which even led to a physical altercation among lawmakers, underscore a deepening judicial crisis within Turkey.
Atalay's journey to the ECHR began after his conviction by an Istanbul court in April 2022, which handed him an 18-year sentence. He was tried alongside activist Osman Kaval, who also remains imprisoned despite multiple rulings for his release. Following his election, Atalay sought to invoke constitutional protections for lawmakers, requesting his release and a suspension of legal proceedings. However, Turkey's highest criminal court, the Court of Cassation, rejected these pleas, deeming his offense an exception to parliamentary immunity and upholding his conviction in September 2023. This defiance set the stage for the current international intervention, as the ECHR now directly challenges Turkey's domestic judicial actions concerning the Can Atalay release order. Atalay turned to the Strasbourg rights court that April, following the termination of his mandate.
Legal Context
The ECHR's ruling explicitly found Atalay's ongoing imprisonment to be unlawful and his exclusion from parliamentary duties unjustified. The European Court of Human Rights Turkey highlighted that the legal framework used to deny him parliamentary immunity lacked sufficient predictability. Crucially, the ECHR judges noted the Court of Cassation's refusal to enforce binding judgments from the Turkish Constitutional Court, which had twice ordered Atalay's release and the suspension of his proceedings in October and December 2023. The ECHR's written judgment emphasized that Atalay remained in detention despite the Constitutional Court's findings of a violation of his right to liberty and security and its explicit orders for his freedom.
The European court's reasoning pointed to several factors indicating a political motivation behind Atalay's detention, including the criminal court's deviation from its established precedents, the initiation of criminal complaints against Constitutional Court judges who supported the initial release order, and public statements from the presidency endorsing this defiance. Bertil Emrah Oder, a professor of constitutional law at Koç University, characterized this situation as one top court actively undermining another, serving as a distinct mechanism for political exclusion. While the ECHR's decision vindicated the Constitutional Court's position, Oder suggested it might have understated the systemic nature of the problem by focusing solely on Atalay's specific circumstances. The ECHR endorsed the Constitutional Court's handling of Atalay’s applications, stopping short of declaring it generally ineffective.
Why It Matters
This latest ECHR order against Turkey represents a significant moment in the ongoing Turkey judicial crisis ECHR. Philip Leach, a professor of human rights law at Middlesex University, underscored the gravity of the situation, stating that targeting a human rights defender despite his parliamentary immunity directly undermines the democratic values protected by the European human rights convention. Leach described the judgment as "another crystal clear marker of the ongoing severe repression of political and democratic rights in Turkey." The ECHR's finding that Atalay's imprisonment served a political purpose—to silence him and suppress pluralism—further amplifies concerns about the erosion of the rule of law.
The defiance shown by the Court of Cassation Turkey Atalay case against both the Turkish Constitutional Court and now the ECHR highlights a troubling pattern. The source notes that numerous similar ECHR judgments have been disregarded by Turkish authorities in the past. This raises serious questions about the enforceability of international legal decisions within Turkey and the independence of its judiciary. As Professor Oder observed, while the Strasbourg court can issue declarations, compliance ultimately rests with domestic authorities. The Turkish Constitutional Court defiance by the highest criminal court sets a dangerous precedent for the separation of powers.
Practical Implications
This development signals a significant erosion of judicial independence and the rule of law in Turkey, as the highest criminal court continues to defy both the Turkish Constitutional Court and the ECHR. Lawyers advising clients with interests in Turkey, particularly those involving human rights, political cases, or international legal obligations, must assess the heightened risk of non-enforcement of judgments and the potential for politically motivated legal outcomes, impacting legal certainty and investment security.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
