
CMA Investigates Bannatyne, Secret Escapes Over Drip Pricing
Summary
- The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has initiated three new investigations into Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes, and Caledonian Travel.
- These probes target concerns about 'drip pricing,' where mandatory charges are not included in the initial advertised price.
- The investigations leverage the CMA's new direct enforcement powers under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA 2024), effective since April 2025.
- Potential penalties for non-compliance include compensation for consumers and fines up to 10% of a company's global turnover.
- This action is part of a broader CMA consumer protection crackdown, which has seen 23 businesses investigated in the past year.
CMA Launches New Probes into Pricing Practices
The CMA's enhanced authority under the DMCCA 2024 allows it to directly enforce consumer law, imposing substantial penalties including compensation orders for affected customers and fines reaching up to 10% of a company's global turnover.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has initiated three new investigations targeting prominent businesses in the leisure and travel sectors: Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes, and Caledonian Travel. These probes stem from concerns that customers are not being presented with the full, total price upfront when purchasing services or holidays, a practice commonly known as 'drip pricing'. This latest action is part of the CMA's ongoing, year-long consumer protection drive, which has seen 23 businesses come under scrutiny since its inception.
The CMA investigates Bannatyne Secret Escapes and Caledonian Travel over allegations that mandatory charges are being separated from the initial headline price and subsequently added later in the buying process. This approach can lead to unexpected additional costs for consumers, making it difficult for them to accurately compare prices across different products and services or to understand the true financial commitment from the outset. The authority emphasizes that businesses across all sectors must review their pricing strategies to ensure compliance with consumer law, or face potential enforcement action.
Enhanced Enforcement Under DMCCA 2024
The legal framework underpinning these investigations is significantly bolstered by the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA 2024), which came into force in April 2025. This legislation grants the CMA enhanced powers to directly determine whether consumer law has been breached, bypassing the need to pursue cases through the courts. The DMCCA 2024 drip pricing enforcement mechanism allows the CMA to impose substantial penalties on non-compliant businesses.
Should an infringement be identified, the CMA can mandate compensation payments to affected customers and levy fines that could reach up to 10% of a company's global turnover. While many businesses have reportedly adjusted their practices to align with new regulations on UK misleading online pricing practices, the CMA continues to identify and address concerns, underscoring the critical need for transparency in online pricing. Lawyers and compliance officers should proactively audit their clients' or companies' online pricing displays to ensure all mandatory charges are included in the upfront headline price, mitigating exposure to CMA investigations and severe financial sanctions.
Specific Allegations and Market Impact
The investigations delve into specific allegations against each company. For Bannatyne Health Club, the CMA is examining concerns that mandatory joining fees and charges for facility access were introduced later in the purchasing journey, rather than being clearly displayed to customers from the start. The Secret Escapes Caledonian Travel investigation focuses on similar issues within the holiday sector.
Caledonian Leisure Ltd, a provider of coach travel and holiday packages, is being investigated over whether its upfront pricing fully includes mandatory fees such as single-person supplements and city taxes. Similarly, Secret Escapes, a prominent travel deals website, faces scrutiny regarding its failure to include mandatory costs like ATOL fees, local taxes, and resort fees, or to accurately represent flight prices, in the total package holiday cost from the initial display. These practices affect millions of UK consumers annually, with over 58 million overseas holidays and 103 million domestic visits made by British residents last year, alongside 11.5 million people belonging to a gym in 2024. At this preliminary stage, the CMA has not reached any conclusions regarding whether the law has been broken in these cases.
CMA's Stance on Consumer Protection
This CMA consumer protection crackdown underscores the authority's commitment to ensuring fair and transparent pricing for consumers. Emma Cochrane, Executive Director for Consumer Protection at the CMA, emphasized the importance of enabling consumers to compare prices on a like-for-like basis, whether they are planning a holiday or selecting a gym membership. She stated that hidden fees should not inflate the final price, and the investigations will determine if businesses were clear about their pricing from the outset.
The CMA's message to businesses is unequivocal: the price customers see upfront should be the price they ultimately pay. The authority's ability to directly enforce consumer law and impose significant financial penalties, including compensation orders, highlights a new era of accountability for online pricing practices. This proactive approach aims to safeguard consumers from unexpected costs and ensure a level playing field for businesses that adhere to transparent pricing standards.
Practical Implications
The CMA's new powers under the DMCCA 2024 enable direct enforcement and significant penalties (up to 10% global turnover, compensation orders) for misleading pricing practices like 'drip pricing'. Lawyers and compliance officers should proactively audit their clients' or companies' online pricing displays to ensure all mandatory charges are included in the upfront headline price, mitigating exposure to CMA investigations and severe financial sanctions.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United Kingdom
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
