B.C. Supreme Court: B.C. Port Picketing Injunction Decision Pending
Summary
- United Steelworkers Local 7619 initiated a strike against Teck Resources’ Highland Valley Copper mine on October 24.
- Secondary picketing by USW at a North Vancouver port terminal, operated by PKM Canada Services Inc., began on November 7.
- PKM Canada Services Inc. and the B.C. Maritime Employers Association sought a B.C. Supreme Court injunction to bar this picketing.
- The court is deliberating whether existing orders from the B.C. Labour Relations Board and the Canada Industrial Relations Board are sufficient to prevent further picketing.
- The unions argue the B.C. Labour Relations Board has exclusive jurisdiction over picket legality, while PKM contends an injunction is necessary due to ongoing vulnerabilities and the involvement of multiple union groups.
What Happened at the Port
He argued that a mere "promise not to do something is just a promise," noting that courts have historically rejected such assurances in favor of issuing injunctive relief.
United Steelworkers Local 7619 initiated a strike against Teck Resources’ Highland Valley Copper mine on October 24. This labor dispute escalated when secondary picketing commenced on November 7 at a North Vancouver port terminal operated by PKM Canada Services Inc. This action prompted PKM, alongside the B.C. Maritime Employers Association, to file a lawsuit alleging that the picketing at the terminal was unlawful and that both the USW and the B.C. Federation of Labour were illegally impeding the port’s operations.
The B.C. Supreme Court recently convened to hear arguments concerning an application for an injunction to prohibit further picketing outside the port. The hearing, initially scheduled for three and a half hours on a Monday, ultimately extended throughout the entire day. A judicial decision on the matter, which will determine whether a B.C. port picketing injunction is warranted to prevent future picketing activities, is anticipated by Thursday afternoon.
Jurisdictional Questions and Union Defenses
Central to the court's deliberation is whether existing interim orders issued by two separate labor bodies adequately address the port's concerns. The B.C. Labour Relations Board (BCLRB) had previously issued an order specifically barring the USW's secondary picketing at the terminal. Concurrently, the Canada Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) mandated that longshore workers disregard a "hot edict" from the B.C. Federation of Labour, which had urged unionized personnel to decline handling materials originating from the mine.
Legal representatives for the B.C. Federation of Labour and the USW contended that the B.C. Supreme Court lacks the authority to issue such an injunction. They asserted that the B.C. Labour Relations Code explicitly grants exclusive jurisdiction over the legality of picket locations to the BCLRB. Furthermore, they characterized an injunction as an extraordinary measure, particularly given the potential for arrests should its terms be violated. The lawyers also highlighted the absence of any secondary picketing at the terminal for the past week, arguing there was no indication that either the USW or the Federation would disregard the labor boards' directives. Both Chris Buchanan, representing the Federation, and William Clements, counsel for the USW, stated they did not foresee a return to picket the location. They even proposed an agreement to refrain from such actions without providing reasonable advance notice to PKM.
PKM's Argument for Court Intervention
Conversely, Ryan Copeland, the lawyer for PKM, strongly advised the court against accepting the unions' proposed agreement. He argued that a mere "promise not to do something is just a promise," noting that courts have historically rejected such assurances in favor of issuing injunctive relief. Copeland emphasized that the existing labor board orders leave PKM vulnerable to potential actions by allied unions and dependent on Teck's discretion regarding the enforcement of the BCLRB's order against secondary picketing at the terminal.
Copeland further explained that PKM is not a direct party to the primary dispute between the USW and Teck, which complicates its ability to enforce the BCLRB's order effectively. He suggested that a PKM Canada Services Inc. injunction might represent the only viable remedy for PKM, providing the necessary certainty for its operations given the high stakes involved. While PKM possesses the authority to enforce the CIRB's order against its own longshore workers, it cannot control the actions of other individuals, such as truck drivers, who might choose to honor a picket line. Copeland also pointed out that the BCLRB's order to end the picket line on November 8 was not immediately effective, as picketing continued into November 9. He observed that the United Steelworkers Local 7619 picketing involved a diverse group of unions, not solely the USW and the B.C. Federation of Labour, indicating that other parties were involved and that the Federation does not control all participants.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising companies affected by or involved in labor disputes in British Columbia should monitor this case for clarity on the jurisdictional boundaries between the B.C. Supreme Court and labor relations boards regarding injunctions against picketing, particularly concerning secondary picketing and the enforceability of existing board orders.
Source
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United States
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
