
ADC Appeals Justice Lifu Judgment: Seeks to Halt INEC Changes for Atiku
Summary
- The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has filed a 17-ground appeal challenging a November 5, 2026 Federal High Court judgment by Justice Peter Lifu.
- The ADC seeks to prevent INEC from altering its leadership records and candidate nominations pending the appeal's resolution.
- The party argues the trial court lacked jurisdiction and is also appealing an earlier July 24, 2026 ruling that allowed an amendment to the originating summons.
- ADC fears premature implementation of the judgment by INEC could undermine its appeal and create uncertainty for its candidates.
- The appeal aims to preserve the party's existing leadership and candidate records, ensuring the appellate court's eventual decision has practical effect.
What Happened
The ADC has expressed significant concern that allowing INEC to implement the November 5 judgment before the Court of Appeal has rendered its decision could severely undermine the ongoing appeal.
The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has lodged a 17-ground appeal with the Court of Appeal, seeking to overturn a judgment delivered by Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court, Abuja, on November 5, 2026. The party has formally requested the appellate court to prevent the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) from making any changes to its official leadership records or the nomination particulars of its presidential and governorship candidates. This injunction is sought pending the full resolution of the appeal.
According to a statement released by Phrank Shaibu, the Director of Strategic Communication for the ADC Campaign Council, the party views the November 5 judgment as fundamentally flawed. The core of the dispute revolves around the leadership structure of the ADC and the legal validity of the processes through which its leadership records and related party affairs are being contested. Justice Lifu's ruling, which stemmed from a suit initiated by Bala Gombe, has introduced fresh legal uncertainty concerning the party's leadership and its preparations for the upcoming 2027 general elections.
Legal Context
Central to the ADC's appeal is the contention that the trial court lacked the necessary jurisdiction to hear the leadership dispute in the first place. The 17 grounds of appeal meticulously challenge various aspects of the lower court's proceedings, including whether the Federal High Court possessed the authority to preside over the matter, whether Bala Gombe had the legal standing to institute the action, how disputed evidence was assessed, and the legality of the sweeping orders issued against the party.
Furthermore, the ADC is pursuing a separate appeal against an earlier ruling from July 24, 2026. This ruling granted Bala Gombe permission to amend his originating summons, a decision the ADC opposed due to an unresolved preliminary objection regarding the court's jurisdiction. The party argues that the proposed amendment improperly altered the description of parties and the capacity in which a defendant was sued, all without obtaining prior leave from the court. Chief J.S. Okutepa (SAN), who leads the ADC's legal team, prepared the appellant's brief for this specific challenge, with the party now urging the Court of Appeal to set aside the amendment order and address the outstanding jurisdictional objection before the trial court. The ADC also highlighted that Justice Lifu proceeded to deliver his November 5 judgment on a court process whose validity was already under challenge before the appellate court.
Why It Matters
The ADC has expressed significant concern that allowing INEC to implement the November 5 judgment before the Court of Appeal has rendered its decision could severely undermine the ongoing appeal. Such premature action, the party warns, could expose its candidates to considerable uncertainty regarding their eligibility and status. Consequently, the ADC has implored the appellate court to preserve the party’s existing leadership and candidate records, maintaining the status quo until the legal dispute is definitively resolved.
The party fears that if INEC acts on the judgment before the appeal is determined, it could create a situation that would be exceedingly difficult to reverse, even if the appellate court ultimately rules in the ADC's favor. Therefore, the ADC is explicitly asking the court to protect the subject matter of the appeal, ensuring that any eventual decision by the appellate court retains its practical effect. The decision to make this legal challenge public was also intended to clarify the issues before the appellate court and reassure the party's members and supporters of its commitment to pursuing the matter through lawful judicial processes.
Practical Implications
Lawyers advising political parties or candidates in Nigeria must closely monitor ongoing appeals, such as the ADC's challenge to Justice Lifu's judgment, as they can create significant uncertainty regarding party leadership, candidate eligibility, and the implementation of electoral processes by INEC. This case highlights the critical importance of seeking stays of execution or injunctions to preserve the status quo pending appeal, especially when a judgment has immediate practical implications for electoral participation.
Source
Source: Original reporting via PUNCH.
How does this affect you?
Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.
Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.
Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in Nigeria
Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.
