FRC Sanctions Saffery LLP, Michael Di Leto: 23 Greensill Audit Breaches
action_required

FRC Sanctions Saffery LLP, Michael Di Leto: 23 Greensill Audit Breaches

United Kingdom·Briefly Analysis⏱️ 4 min read

Summary

  • The FRC sanctioned Saffery LLP and audit partner Michael Di Leto for 23 breaches in the FY2019 audit of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited.
  • Breaches included failures in risk assessment, revenue recognition, expected credit loss, and going concern evaluations.
  • The audit work suffered from a lack of understanding of GCUK's business model and insufficient professional skepticism.
  • GCUK, a working capital finance provider, entered administration in March 2021, though the FRC stated the audit breaches did not cause this.
  • Saffery and Mr. Di Leto have implemented remedial actions, the effectiveness of which will be assessed by the FRC.

FRC Sanctions Saffery LLP and Audit Partner

The FRC underscored the critical importance of the going concern assumption in financial reporting, noting its fundamental role in financial statement preparation and its reliance by users for investment and other key decisions.

The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has issued a Final Settlement Decision Notice (FSDN) under its Audit Enforcement Procedure, imposing sanctions on Saffery LLP and its Audit Engagement Partner, Mr. Michael Di Leto. This action stems from an investigation into the statutory audit of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (GCUK) for the financial year ending December 31, 2019. Both Saffery and Mr. Di Leto have admitted to 23 distinct breaches of relevant requirements concerning this audit.

The breaches were deemed serious and pervasive, affecting numerous critical aspects of the FY2019 audit. These included deficiencies in planning and risk assessments, audit work related to accounting policies, revenue recognition, expected credit loss calculations, and, significantly, the assessment of GCUK's going concern status. Further failings were identified in the review of audit evidence, the operation of audit quality control, and the overall exercise of professional skepticism throughout the engagement. The respondents were also ordered to cover the costs associated with the Executive Counsel's investigation.

Pervasive Audit Deficiencies at Greensill Capital

The FRC's findings highlight a profound failure by the auditors to adequately address several significant risks identified during the audit of GCUK, which served as the primary trading entity for the Australian-headquartered Greensill Group. These unaddressed risks included the potential for material misstatement arising from revenue recognition practices, the risk of management override of controls, and issues related to the valuation and recovery of assets. A critical flaw was also identified in the audit work pertaining to the appropriateness of management’s use of the going concern basis of accounting in preparing the financial statements.

The fundamental issues underpinning these audit failures were attributed to a lack of proper understanding of GCUK’s complex business model, which involved supplying various forms of working capital finance, and the inherent risks associated with it. This lack of comprehension, coupled with an insufficient application of professional skepticism, meant that the audit work performed did not adequately respond to the identified challenges. While the FRC acknowledged the breaches in going concern assessment, it clarified that these did not cause GCUK's eventual administration, which occurred in March 2021 after the company ceased new business operations due to difficulties in renewing trade credit insurance.

Emphasizing Audit Quality and Remedial Actions

The FRC underscored the critical importance of the going concern assumption in financial reporting, noting its fundamental role in financial statement preparation and its reliance by users for investment and other key decisions. Auditors are therefore expected to ensure this assumption is based on accurate information and considers all relevant circumstances impacting an entity's viability. This case serves as a stark reminder of the stringent expectations placed on statutory auditors, particularly regarding their duty to exercise robust professional skepticism and thoroughly understand client operations.

Since the FY2019 audit, Saffery has initiated changes and improvements to its general audit processes and procedures. Similarly, Mr. Di Leto has undertaken remedial steps aimed at addressing some of the identified failings and related breaches. While the effectiveness of these measures has not yet been formally assessed, the FRC's order includes provisions to determine the efficacy of these changes to audit methodology and the remedial steps already implemented. The cooperation of both respondents with the Executive Counsel's investigation was also noted.

Practical Implications

Lawyers advising audit firms or companies subject to statutory audits should note the FRC's stringent enforcement regarding audit quality, particularly concerning going concern assessments, risk identification, and professional skepticism. This case highlights the need for robust internal controls and thorough understanding of client business models to avoid significant breaches and sanctions under the Audit Enforcement Procedure.

Source

Source: Original reporting via Financial Reporting Council press notice.

Get Deeper AI analysis

How does this affect you?

Get an AI analysis of this article grounded in your jurisdictions, practice areas, and any policy documents you've uploaded to Wansom.

Finish Reading the Full Story and the Expert Analysis.

Get the latest legal & regulatory intelligence in United Kingdom

Instant access to full analysis, cited statutes & expert commentary
Customize your dashboard to track what matters to your business operations

Already have an account? Log in

Wansom is AI and can make mistakes.